» Home » Politics
Ηiroshima Was Not Necessary
Japan was already militarily defeated and would have surrendered eventually.
 polIywog  04 Jul 2012 00:16
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
[Comments deleted by user]
 
 pollywog  04 Jul 2012 09:07
 Add a Comment
 
Yes, the Japanese military situation was hopeless. But the civilian one was not.

What most people fail to realise is that Japanese citizens wouldn't have surrendered, even if the Emperor did. An Allied invasion of Japan (what would have been necessary for a surrender) would have cost over a million American lives, and many more from the remaining nations that would have been involved. Prior to the supposed invasion of Japan in 1945, American factories crammed out over a million Purple Hearts, which are given to dead soldiers. With the bombing, America has instead been able to use these Purple Hearts for wars since then. In fact, I believe they are still using those manufactured all those years ago.

I'm not saying that bombing two cities with a nuclear device was good. But it saved more lives bombing Hiroshima and Nagasaki that would have been lost in an Allied invasion.
 
 limyaael  21 Jul 2012 02:30
 Add a Comment
 
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
The Current Fear Is Neither Global Warming Nor The Coming Ice Age.
It Is Not Racist To Profile Crimes
There Is Great Common Ground Between Conservatives And Liberals
Politics Makes Strange Bed-fellows.
The Same Press/People That Faulted Bush For His Slow Response To Katrina Are Strangely Silent On Obama's...
There Is A Holocaust Coming. It Will Be Upon Women, And Women Are Bringing It Upon Themselves.
Sarah Palin Is Pretty
Mccain Is The Perfect Person To Run Our Country
This Administration Is Preaching Responsibility Than Having Big Costly Black Tie Affairs
Huckabee Is The Best Republican
New Debates
V-Chips?
Should The Development Of New Technology Be Stopped?
12+ Dating
Flutes Are Better Than Clarinets
Skittles Are Better Than Ring Pops
Should Kids Be Able To Drive At 13
Urgent Urgent Help Is Needed
K2 Should Be Banned!!!!!!!
Marriage Is Strictly Religious And Between A Man And Woman
There Is No Fixed And/or Physical Center Of The Universe.