» Home » Health
When A Parent Drags A Screaming Child Around The Supermarket By The Arm, They Should Be Arrested For Assault.
Have you ever wanted to role your sleeves up and intervene, when you see a parent fail to be a good mother or father? People who have children owe it to them to bring them up, not drag them up.
 keepmindok  18 Jul 2008 10:26
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
I agree that if one wishes to become a parent they should be prepared to exercise patience, and actually RAISE the child.
I mean, why have them if you don't plan to care for them properly?
What's the point?
 
 Scorpion  12 Aug 2008 21:40
 Add a Comment
 
And how would you deal with a child having a temper tantrum when you absolutely must get your shopping done in a certain amount of time?
 
 Lynn  23 Nov 2008 11:15
 1 Comment
 
 Have you seen the advert where the mother throws herself to the floor of the supermarket and has a tantrum ?
She then gets up. And without a word....
The stunned toddler quietly shrinks to his mothers side.;-))
by  keepmindok
 23 Nov 2008 11:29
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I kind of agree parents shouldn't but you will be surprised that most parents avoid this and then slap you when you get home .
 
 YoungRuva  06 Aug 2008 17:10
 2 Comments
 
 A little pat on the but is usually enough to get a kids attention.
If is it done with love not anger.
If a parent needs to keep slapping that child, I would question it especially if the child is grown up.
by  keepmindok
 11 Aug 2008 09:22
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Hell, it saves me smacking the whining little ----'s.
 
 Snipex  23 Jul 2008 23:09
 2 Comments
 
 Kids deserve better.
by  keepmindok
 24 Jul 2008 14:09
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
So bad parents should be arrested? Even if we accept that what you describe is bad parenting I think your conclusion is insane.
 
 Quincel  22 Jul 2008 16:22
 3 Comments
 
 A parent dragging a child around by the arm is poor parenting, anyone else dragging a person around any where would draw significant attention. I would be surprised if the police weren't called and the perpetrator isn't arrested for assault. What makes it more repugnant when it is a child is the emotional trauma.
by  keepmindok
 22 Jul 2008 17:33
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I have tried to "reason" with a child before.

Actually I have tried with all 4 of my kids.

I wish people would understand that some kids just have a meltdown and there is nothing else to do but hurry up, buy the items and get back home.

No parent is proud to have to resort to those tactics but sometimes that is what it takes.

The best scenario is to be able to shop with 2 adults so that one can remove the child if a tantrum starts but that is not always possible.

I have been known to push my cart to the front of the store and tell a cashier that I'm sorry but since my kids can't behave we won't be buying any groceries today and could they re-stock them for me.

Doesn't take too many times of that before they learn to behave.
 
 panistapsa  22 Jul 2008 16:20
 3 Comments
 
 praise where it's due. point taken, you found a solution which left you in complete control of the situation and taught the kids a valuable lesson.
by  keepmindok
 23 Jul 2008 01:40
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I think its wrong when parents have their kids on a leash, like dogs.
But i'd you had kids, and have been in that situation with a screaming kid, then you would want to roll your sleeves just so you could spank the hell out of the kid. Lol. Of course not in a an abusive way, but they need it sometimes.
 
 lq04  22 Jul 2008 01:39
 1 Comment
 
 Iq04 reigns are O.K. for their purpose, they could prevent kids from getting bloody knees or run over. They might need a skelp and a cursory reminder. that is not the scenario above.
by  keepmindok
 23 Jul 2008 02:21
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
If the child is not behaving, and is uncontrollable then yes the parent should have the right to take them out of the store. As long as the parent is not hitting them or something like that then it's OK. Plus it's not fair to other shoppers if they have to listen to a child screaming, and throwing a fit in the store.
 
 1993tress  21 Jul 2008 21:32
 1 Comment
 
 Yes 1993stress, this is the point isn't it, when the parent takes the child aside and others aren't rubbernecking it's just between them, then the kid isn't embarrassed and more able to see reason. The scenario describe just escalates the situation. The discerning public know the score.
by  keepmindok
 23 Jul 2008 01:53
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I believe that the parent is simply trying to be firm with their child. I certainly wouldn't say that it should be classed as assault. It is entirely up to the parent as to how they discipline their own child.

Screaming children need to be disciplined otherwise they end up being spoilt. If a parent looks as though they are attempting to discipline their child in a reasonable manner (and I believe that dragging them by the arm is reasonable if the child is screaming) then it is best not to intervene. However, if a parent is obviously abusing their child, such as punching them or displaying some other form of violence towards them, then perhaps you could voice your concerns to someone such as the police rather than the parent, to save a confrontation.
 
 louise23  21 Jul 2008 19:00
 Add a Comment
 
 
Perhaps you just wanted to make this debate to spark controversy, but I believe that you don't have the right and will never gain the right to tell a parent how to punish their children, many parents feel that it is their right to parent their children how they want to, if a child is misbehaving and you see it, you can never "intervene" as you said. Maybe that parent isn't smacking them across the face or the butt like you want them too because they believe that they shouldn't spank their children. And vice versa. If the parent wants to give them a little pat on the butt, then that's what they believe gets the point across. I strongly disbelieve in your statement and opinion
 
 123  21 Jul 2008 08:03
 Add a Comment
 
 
I care for a 4 year old in the body of a 64 year old woman with dementia and physchotic issues too numerous to list. I have to physically restrain her, hold on to her or she will wander off on a whim for a coke. Follow any kind-hearted pervert to his car and bend over for caffeine and sugar, a cigarette. I feel like an ogre, but she cant remember anything 3 minutes after a detailed discussion on what I need her to do, like stay beside me. I am only trying to keep her safe. She will shape a dozen falls in front of anyone to get a wheel chair that she does not need. Shaped falls so perfected I could rent her out for a stunt-woman in the movies. A woman at rehab saw me ignore the request for a coke. She went without asking and bought her one knowing nothing about my ward. She had no clue if this woman was on dialysis, or that the load of a coke could kill her!!! Or that a trip to WalMart was coming and the load on her kidneys would find her peeing on the floor. I refrained from telling her to butt-out ,or explain her private issues. Just returned the can and said, "No Thanks. The parent dragging her kid could have just let go and let the child run into the arms of a stranger. Then called the cops to report a kidnapping.
Keepmindok. You don't know diddly. I don't see one thumbs up comment that supports your rant.
 
 Kay-O-Kay  19 Jul 2008 07:36
 1 Comment
 
 O-k
by  keepmindok
 19 Jul 2008 15:33
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
You evidently don't have kids. Parents who appear to be dragging their children around the store are probably disciplining them for something. At least they are paying attention to their children. Those who do not pay attention to their children are the ones who be arrested. Above all, you should mind your own business. Parents know their children best and what they do with their children is their business, not yours. Parents should have ever right to discipline their children if they want to and they should be allowed to discipline them however they want to. However, if they really do harm the child such as making them bleed or disciplining them for no reason, then they should be arrested for assault.
 
 Professor  19 Jul 2008 03:50
 Add a Comment
 
 
The child first of all prolly deserves what ever punishment the parent is giving too them ... And its a parents choice if they want too hit the child or not .. Its OK in so many ways
 
 uriah34  18 Jul 2008 21:34
 1 Comment
 
 The child deserves proper treatment. If both the adult and the parent are out of control someone should do something.
by  keepmindok
 23 Jul 2008 02:14
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
WOW!! What a bold statement ASSAULT. You should come by my house. You would probably want to have me arrested. There is nothing wrong with tough love. If you baby a child they grow up to be pansies. Look disciplining children has been around for years it's part of growing up. But I'm sure you will have something to say. You obviously wear you heart on your sleeve , since you have had a rebuttal for every opinion. People like you don't belong on this website. It's "For and Against" not CRY AND PLEAD YOUR CASE. Get over yourself!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
 Longhorn  18 Jul 2008 19:47
 Add a Comment
 
 
It really depends on whether the parent is physically abusing the child or whether they are just trying to control a child throwing a tantrum. How would you know unless it was obvious? I would agree that children who are brought up well tend to behave better, but they are all capable of kicking off and having a wobbler every now and again. On the other hand, if the parent was dragging the child around by the leg, then it would be a good idea to intervene.
 
 Jahwobble  18 Jul 2008 16:52
 1 Comment
 
 Yes I can just hear Marvin on till seven calling for security.
Kids are all capable, and do kick off but the more the parent is in control of the child the better it would pan out. Reason with reason.
It starts when they are tiny tots and it gets more and more difficult to sort out the older they get.
You make some fair comments thanks.
by  keepmindok
 18 Jul 2008 17:08
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
We should all be fortunate enough to be half as wise as keepmindok appears to think they are. The more self righteous liberals talk the more I appreciate my 2nd Amendment rights!
 
 Cons_Lies  18 Jul 2008 13:38
 2 Comments
 
 I don't think I have been self righteous. I just think children deserve love and understanding. If they are being treated as described, they are clearly not.
Don't shoot the messenger.
Why not just stick to the debate.
by  keepmindok
 18 Jul 2008 13:52
Comment