» Home » Environment
Whaling Is An Ecologically Sustainable Enterprise.
Those who oppose whaling are quick to talk of how cruel and inhumane it is. But other than ethical issues, are there other reasons we should not allow Japan and other nations to hunt whales? The Minke whale, the most hunted whale is in fact also the most abundant whale, and we all know that it is in no way in these countries' interest to drive whales to extinction. I have researched this thoroughly, and believe that whaling IS sustainable.
 chaew  05 May 2008 09:57
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
Whales are the enemy. Do the whale defenders realise how many fish whales eat? Up to 500 million tonnes per year - vastly more than all human fishing combined. Fish stocks are running low around the world in part due to the predatory action of greedy whales.

Whales are so big they have hardly any natural predators except us. So by imposing a special ban on hunting them, we are removing the natural check which nature placed on their numbers. As a result, whales are proliferating and fish stocks are being ravaged.
Anyone who saves a whale is actually condemning hundreds of thousands, maybe millions, of fish to death through being eaten alive over the course of the whale's lifetime. Why should the whale's life be more valuable than the lives of all those fish?

Whale brains are larger than human brains, yet they have failed to develop any advanced technology such as space ships. Water, the natural environment of whales, makes up two thirds of the earth's surface; land only one third. Despite this, it was a land creature, man, that rose to dominance on the planet. This shows that whales are a failed species.

By now, they should probably have been the dominant life-form on the planet, flying over us in whale aircraft, hunting us down for food or "scientific research". There should be internal campaigns within whale society about whether or not they should "Save the Human" and debates about whether hunting humans was ecologically sustainable. Instead, it's the other way around. Whales had their chance and fluffed it. They are a failed species and we have indulged them with too much pity.
 
 Hidell  05 May 2008 10:34
 1 Comment
 
 Lmao I would like to hear more about the tragic story of the Whales' failed quest for world dominance. Was there a traitor among them whose greed led to the collapse of their empire in WWI (Whale War 1) or was it a case of the underdogs (us humans) emerging as the ultimate species against all odds?
by  chaew
 05 May 2008 10:39
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Yes. Yes it is. The Minke Whale is in abundant supply and is in no danger of extinction. However, many coastal societies depend on whaling as a source of food. In addition, the reason USA wants a ban on whaling is so that these poor coastal regions have to import food from America, and thus improve the American economy.
 
 ibanex_87  05 May 2008 10:13
 1 Comment
 
 Science coursework came in handy there Dom :P
by  Carl
 05 May 2008 11:51
Comment
  
Comment
  
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
People Should Make More Conservation Efforts For Animals
Environment Is Our HOME....
Global Warming Is A Global Conspiracy
We Cannot Save Planet Earth Unless There Is The Necessary Political Will To Do So.
Orangutans Are Going To Be Extinct Due To Their Land/ Habitats Being Reduced In The Next 10-15 Years
The American Language Should Not Be Changed To The English Language.
Earth Hour Is A Waste Of Time!!!!!
China America And India Are Polluting The World
It Will Snow In New Hampshire On April 2nd, 2009.
We Should Rely More On Alternative Energy Rather Than Fossil Fuels
New Debates
Nuclear Energy Is No Longer Harmful
We Should Just Say 'Merry Non-Religious Winter Solstice Event'.
CHESS: It Is Not The Game You Are Playing:
All's Fair In Love And War Is True:
Women Prefer Cyrano De Bergerac To Mr.Perfect:
Everyone, Has A "Type" They Are Attracted To Most:
Stalin Did It For The Lulz
Receive My Exports, Girls, U Know You Want To
They Walk Among Us
It's Over 9000!!!!111 It Is!!!11111@