» Home » Miscellaneous
It Is Against A Person's Human Rights To Be Punished For The Outcome
A man drives 100 miles per hour on a busy road but does not cause death or injury. No accidents occurs. Another driver is doing 10 miles per hour over the speed limit and ten people are killed when he is involved in a crash. He faces years in prison. Does that seem fair? I mean you should be punished for your actions. You don't control the outcome.
 DAVIDB  12 Mar 2008 12:50
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
The US justice system should focus more on the perpetrator's motivations, as well as on his/her actions, rather than on unintended consequences. The person who drove a mere 10 miles over the speed limit and accidentally killed several people in the process would have enough guilt to live with for the rest of his life that slapping on a lengthy prison sentences seems truly unwarranted.

This debate, however, touches on some of the deep flaws inherent in the American justice system, and perhaps to a lesser degree the regimes of other countries as well. Penalties for relatively minor crimes in the US are grossly inflated and do not reflect the actual seriousness of the given crime or felony. It is completely unreasonable to give those caught trafficking in controlled substances decades in prison, to threaten people who use the services of a prostitute with jail time or to hand down multiple life sentences for any crime. Additionally, the US practice of offering parole after 85 percent of a sentence has been served seems excessive as well. A good, recent example of this is the fate of disgraced media mogul Conrad Black.
 
 mackenzie  12 Mar 2008 13:08
 1 Comment
 
 wise...very wise

How do you feel about Scott Peterson receiving the death penalty though?
by  aisle10
 08 Apr 2008 05:42
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I presume this is hypothetical. How did he kill 10 people?
 
 StBalders  12 Mar 2008 12:57
 Add a Comment
 
It makes no sense to punish people for the outcome. The outcome is just luck. That's like tossing a coin to decide which prisoners to let out when you need room in the jail.
 
 ur_wrong  06 Oct 2008 05:57
 Add a Comment
 
 
Outcome is definite and factual. It's the best way we can accurately measure someones crime and punish them accordingly.
 
 Specter87  29 Sep 2008 03:07
 Add a Comment
 
 
No it's not unfair because the guy driving 100 mph. Did not kill anyone , the other guy did kill so yes it's fair he should go to jail.
 
 nelson12  12 Mar 2008 16:21
 Add a Comment
 
 
If they guy had been caught speeding, he would have been punished, but we have to punish based on the outcome. There is a difference between murder and attempted murder - even when the same action could have ended up with either outcome.
There are 2 factors involved here:
1) It only matters if something is legal or not when you get caught.
2) Someone who kills ten people in a car accident has done more damage to society than a person speeding, so their penalty should be more severe (using our current notions of justice).
 
 Moegreche  12 Mar 2008 12:58
 2 Comments
 
 Not true. Y'es more damage has been caused but that's not the point. It is against a persons human rights to be punished for the outcome.

If you attempt to commit a crime you should receive the same punishment as someone who has been successful.

You can take a baseball bat to someone and they could survive and yet you could lose your temper and punched a person once and they die.
by  DAVIDB
 12 Mar 2008 13:07
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
Becky Is A Pretty Name
All The Religion Postings Are More Like A Battle
Paris Hilton Is A Better Influence On Teenagers Than Britney Spears
Ninjas Are Awesome
You Can Get Your Best Work Done In The Middle Of The Night.
Homelessness Is A Problem Caused By Society!
There Should Be No Cars
Evolutionists Have An Incredible Imagination
Spider-Man Better Than Superman
Gun Ownership Should Be Strictly Controlled
New Debates
Is Hydrogen Poroxide A Good Ingredien For Experiments Like Elephant Toothpaste.
MacDonalds Should Be Banned
Porche 911 Turbo Is A Noticable Car On The Streets.
If You Meet An Alien It Will Suck Out Your Brains.
Chicken Is Nice
That My Brother Doesn't Have A Dick
That Modern Technology Is A Plague On Human Relationships
Technology Is Tearing Us A Criminal
Technology Is Tearing Us A Part
Diet Coke And Mentos Is One Of The Best Experiments.