» Home » Politics
Spreading The Wealth Is Giving YOUR Money To Other People Who Didn't Work For It
You know what I'm saying
 melisiwa  17 Dec 2008 19:54
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
Yes, spreading the wealth is giving your money to people who haven't worked for it. But, sometimes those people need the help. There are some who try hard to make it in society, yet they get rejected despite their efforts. I think that it is good to spread the wealth sometimes (for those who truly deserve it).
 
 SlyOne  21 Dec 2008 07:06
 Add a Comment
 
 
The popular term is "redistribution of wealth" and the concept was advocated by karl marx (father of socialism) who said, from each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs. Translation: Those who are most able in our society have a responsibility to care for those with the highest need.

The flaw in this philosophy is that you can certainly pass laws to make sure everyone is living in similar circumstances, but you cannot legislate the application of talent. If you remove the reward, you will eliminate much of the incentive for achievement.
 
 kyrosin1  17 Dec 2008 22:11
 3 Comments
 
 Surely there is a happy medium. You needn't rule out socialism alltogether, just as you cannot ignore reward for talent and hard work.
by  StBalders
 17 Dec 2008 22:17
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
That's a very conservative way of putting it.
 
 Specter87  17 Dec 2008 20:55
 Add a Comment
 
 
What else could it be? It takes from one group and gives to another for nothing more than because one group has more than the other. Socialism. Liberalism. Whatever you want to call it....it sucks for the hardworking members of society.
 
 created  17 Dec 2008 20:50
 1 Comment
 
 You have a studder?
by  Specter87
 20 Dec 2008 02:35
Comment
  
Comment
  
Capitalism is the only fair and honest form of government that has ever existed.
 
 Mystery  18 Dec 2008 04:22
 3 Comments
 
 "fair and honest form of government" - there is no such thing.
by  Specter87
 20 Dec 2008 02:28
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I don't think anybody spreads the wealth anymore, so this debate is almost pointless.
 
 bookworm3  17 Dec 2008 22:53
 1 Comment
 
 umm this new healthcare reform, social security, medicare and medicade, TAXES in general, i can keep going....
by  kh92
 20 Nov 2009 15:57
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
It includes them (that in turn includes those who cannot work). But then your statement ignores those who do work hard for little pay, those who work hard caring for a relative, the pensioners who have worked hard all their lives, some even fought wars for us. I am sure this list can be added to.
 
 StBalders  17 Dec 2008 21:41
 Add a Comment
 
 
Spreading wealth? Maybe you mean taxes.
 
 imright20  17 Dec 2008 21:36
 Add a Comment
 
 
Spreading the Wealth isn't, taxation is.
 
 Quincel  17 Dec 2008 20:10
 Add a Comment
 
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
If America Turns On Israel We Will Lose God's Protection. Obama And Biden's Stance On Building In Jerusalem...
Communism Is Not Bad.
Chapstick For President
Today's Liberals Put Ideology Above What Works
McCain Is Playing A Game
There Is A Shadow Government Running The World. Currently They Are Working On The U.S.-- Intimidating...
Boris Johnson Should Use His Real Name
We Will Never REALLY Know If Obama Believes The Holocaust Happened
Text Messages Should Be Private.
Its Ok To Go After Obama's Wife
New Debates
Fatherlessness Is Perhaps The Most Tragic And Consequential Social Ill.
There Is No Excuse For Being Unhealthy
The Future Of The US Is Really Between The Conservatives And The Demolibrarepublicanocrats
All The User Request For Changes On This Site For The Past Couple Of Years With No Change Or Response...
Porn Should Not Be Allowed In Sperm Clinics
AR454 Is A Violent Homophobic Thug Who Should Be Sectioned For The Good Of The Greater Public.
Stereotypical Gender Roles Do Not Apply In This Day And Age.
A Person Should Be Forced To Donate A Kidney If They Are Found To Be A Match For Someone Who Will Otherwise...
The Next Big Bubble To Burst Is The Higher Education Bubble
Unhealthy Relationships Between Friends