» Home » History
Some Historian Said That Pearl Harbor Was A Cover Up
I could not believe this guy when he said roolivet covered it up
 kingbaddog  10 Jul 2008 00:49
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
I really doubt that even though he wanted to join the war Roosevelt would purposely have his people killed as a excuse to join the war. I am guessing though that when it happened he jumped on it like a tiger.
 
 Smito  10 Jul 2008 14:23
 1 Comment
 
 Roosevelt purposefully provoked the Japanese into bombing the harbotr by cutting off their oil supply to China, because as we all know, Japan has always been out to take china ever since imperialism started. Once he did cut the oil the Japanese started to secretly send messages to the Japanese embassy and the US then interpretted it by overhearing their transmissions. A set of letters called the seven pages told the embassy where they would strike and when even, UP TO THE HOUR! and all Roosevelt did was tell them to set up the steel nets and put the planes wingtip to wingtip. Once we did relay the seventh page of the seven pages, it was too late, by three hours because just by coincidence the radios and com. lines were out. Definitely a cover up to something larger
by  123
 19 Jul 2008 23:32
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Quite a few historians have expressed the view that the Pearl Harbour attack was deliberately provoked by Franklin Roosevelt as a way to get the United States into the Second World War despite the isolationist instincts of its people. In fact, this is now pretty much proved beyond any reasonable doubt, though it hasn't yet filtered through into popular consciousness.

If you do a Google search on the term "McCollum memorandum" you will find a document setting out a number of steps which Roosevelt planned to follow to goad Japan into attacking America. All of these were followed and the attack eventually came about. Read the book "Day of Deceit" by Robert Stinnett if you want to know more.

There is also a second strand of this conspiracy theory which holds that Roosevelt knew specifically that the attack was coming to Pearl Harbour on December 7th and chose not to pass the information on to those at the base. This relies mainly on the argument that the Japanese communications were being intercepted and their codes broken, so Roosevelt must have known.
 
 Hidell  10 Jul 2008 01:29
 3 Comments
 
 If he knew they were coming he could have sent a handful of the fleet ships out a ways to take the hit near Pearl Harbor without actually letting the base itself be ruined nearly defenseless. The public would still have been outraged, the country would still have gone to war.
by  Grenache
 10 Jul 2008 14:28
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
The fundamental flaw in blaming Roosevelt for Pearl Harbor is it ignores Japanese history itself in the decade preceding the attack. Japan was expanding militarily on all fronts in the Pacific, was jabbing hard into China, and had no other power standing in its way in the Pacific except for the US. Japan's attack on our main Pacific fleet was inevitable even if a different person had been our President.
 
 Grenache  10 Jul 2008 14:22
 1 Comment
 
 Japan was extremely reluctant to attack the US. The oil blockade forced its hand, as it was intended to do.
by  Hidell
 10 Jul 2008 14:37
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I trust roosevelt
 
 kingbaddog  10 Jul 2008 00:50
 Add a Comment
 
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
The Suffragettes Did Not Do Their Cause Any Good.
History Is Really Important
Martin Luther King Was Assassinated By The US Government
Just Because Your Last Name Is "Klann", It Doesn't Mean That You Are Related To The People In The KKK...
The Majority Of People Who Have Ever Lived Are Not Alive Today.
James Bond Has As Much Historical Reality As Jesus
Due To The Fact That Hitler Had A Different Life Before Becoming A Mass Murder, He Had A Mental Disorder...
The Truth About The Princes In The Tower Has Been Hidden From The Public By The Monarchy.
The Holocaust Really Happened!
Hitler Was A Christian
New Debates
Does Society Consider The U.S. Marine's To Be Modern Day Spartan's.
Youtube Needs A Great Deal More Censorship And Regulations.
Nonconformists Are All Alike?
The Printing-Press Was The Greatest Historical Invention Of All-Time
Bill Clinton Should Be Allowed To Run For President Again
Cster Is A Big Meanie!
Paranormal “Investigating” Is A Pseudoscience
To Say You Are Joking To Get Away With Meanness Is A Social-Lie
Adults Should Be Allowed To Eat Off The Kids Menu.
Very Little Food We Buy These Days Is Good For Your Health.