» Home » Science
Skill And Knowledge Overcome Luck And Superstition.
Always and forever
 Teachdirt  13 Apr 2008 04:12
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
Yes. Success doesn't happen by accident.
 
 keepmindok  29 Jul 2008 12:32
 Add a Comment
 
 
I think luck DOES exist, but I agree skill and knowledge do help you more often and more reliably.
 
 veggiefry  17 Apr 2008 18:26
 Add a Comment
 
 
There really isn't luck, it's just random circumstance that may help or hinder our particular desires. It doesn't happen because we have luck, we identify it as luck if it happens.

Superstition is likewise silly, it's people misidentifying the actual cause of events because they feel better about inventing an irrational cause than simply accepting the reality of it.
 
 Cephus  15 Apr 2008 00:35
 1 Comment
 
 Luck is a game of chance.
by  kontar1
 15 Apr 2008 05:52
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
If you look at a professional poker player... Its not luck they depend on... Its skill
 
 Azmatan  14 Apr 2008 12:39
 1 Comment
 
 But without a bit of luck, or at least avoiding being unlucky they would not be so successful. Any poker player would say it requires a bit of good fortune to win a major tournament. It has been estimated at 80% skill 20% luck.
by  StBalders
 14 Apr 2008 12:44
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Yes they do. Superstition when we break it down to its fundamentals is rather daft and has no affect on anything. Touch wood. Luck is slightly different but it evens itself out over time. I might get lucky and knock the best poker player in the world out of a tournament but if I played him 10 more times he would beat me more often than not.
 
 StBalders  13 Apr 2008 13:20
 Add a Comment
 
 
Duh. Luck doesn't really exist, it's just what we say when we don't understand how we won. Superstition is just our poorly produced explanation of how we won.

This isn't an argument. The words are defined this way and anyone who disagrees doesn't understand English.
 
 JohnShier  13 Apr 2008 04:27
 1 Comment
 
 Of course luck exists. it is something that happens to our benefit that is beyond our control. The rub of the green, lap of the gods. I saw the leader of the masters get very lucky yesterday when his ball was heading to the water but just managed to cling to the side of the bank. 9 times out of 10 it would have been wet, the fact it didn't was down to good luck. Of course if he goes on to win it is because he played with incredible skill, but all winners have an element of good fortune somewhere along the line.
by  StBalders
 13 Apr 2008 13:39
Comment
  
Comment
  
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
Everyone Involved In This Debate Is Smart.
Animal Testing Is Not Cruel
NASA Is Awesome
In Science, The Term “theory” Does Not Translate To “opinion” Or “speculation”.
Global Climate Change Is Natural
If Homosexuality Comes From Genes, The Genes Should Be "Fixed"
We Exist In The Fourth Dimension.
Attempts To Create Parahumans Should Be Welcomed.
Scientific Naturalists Have No Reason To Be Proud Of Their Minds
People Need To Do The Research And Study Evolution Their Selves.
New Debates
The Simpsons Is One Of The Best Cartoons Of All Time?
Energy Can Be Created And Destroyed
The Design Theory Is Flawed.
The Bible Was Written By Naive People.
Having A Boyfriend/girlfriend In High School Causes Lots Of Unnecessary Drama.
A Likely Reason Why Students Are Forced To Take Classes That They Don't Really Need For The Major They...
Sneezing When Looking At A Bright Light Is Caused By The Microbes In The Nose Reacting To The Light....
There Should Be Mild Sedatives In Prison Food.
Many Atheists Have Been Hurt By The Myths Of Santa, The Tooth Fairy And Easter Bunny. They Believed...
Fatties Should Take A Tip From Smokers. To Ward Off Those Cravings For Chips They Should Sellotape A...