» Home » Society
You Should Go To Jail For Denying The Holocaust
I know that you can go to jail in Austria if you deny it. Do you think this is fair?
 moreno  25 May 2008 23:48
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
As someone who has both had family in Aushwit bearkenu,(sp), and heard them tell their account of what happened and visited the place themselves, I feel that anyone denying that it happened should go see it, see the finger nail marks on the walls of the gas chambers.
You can feel the evil in the place, no one smiles, no one laughs, because you can feel the anger and hate.
I am never one to go all gooey, and talk about my feelings, but that place was evil, and should never be denied, because then, if it is denied, it can be repeated
 
 martlamb  03 Jun 2008 19:11
 4 Comments
 
 That doesn't mean they should go to jail because they don't feel your pain. No president or any leadership has apologized for slavery yet.
Should some Americans be thrown in jail for not apologizing because they don't feel the need to apologize? One could argue thats denying.
by  moreno
 03 Jun 2008 19:35
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
It makes perfect sense for countries that were involved in the Holocaust, or that were aligned with Hitler's Germany during the War, to make Holocaust denial illegal. Throughout the postwar period, West Germany has had to keep skinheads and crypto-Nazis at bay, especially because so many former Nazis had made their way back into the public service in the early 1950s. As such, de-Nazification hardly happened in the West, and there was a risk that anti-Semitic, far-right groups may one day turn into a powerful political force.

Both Germany and Austria have fairly stringent laws when it comes to Holocaust denial. In fact, we probably all remember how David Irving, Britain's shameful pseudo-historian and Holocaust denier, was put on trial and then sentenced to prison in Austria for about a year. It is especially important that Austria maintain these laws against Holocaust denial, as this country has had a reputation of denying, or sugar-coating its own World War II history.
 
 mackenzie  26 May 2008 07:07
 Add a Comment
 
 
Its really, its dam really and if you deny it and go to prison, well it serves you right.
 
 higack  26 May 2008 00:25
 1 Comment
 
 Serves you right for what, A state of mind?
by  moreno
 26 May 2008 00:35
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Sure. They deserve it.
 
 Mark  25 May 2008 23:52
 1 Comment
 
 for what? being stupid? people should not be in jail for stupidity
they should be educated
and... maybe forced to pick up litter wearing a visi jacket on a busy road
by  JackLC
 25 May 2008 23:54
Comment
  
Comment
  
As sick and repulsive is too deny the Holocaust I don' t think one should be sent to jail for it. All rational people know the Holocaust happened but we have to allow freedom of speech no matter how ugly it is. It could give governments power to take away freedoms in other areas.
These deniers should just be ridiculed and laughed at, they are just pathetic.
 
 kddan  14 Oct 2008 20:56
 1 Comment
 
 Pretty much a more detailed version of what I said.
by  AxemRanger
 14 Oct 2008 23:43
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
As ignorant as it is to say that the Holocaust never happened, I do not believe you should necessarily go to jail for it. You are entitled to believe what you want. I know, for a fact, that it happened, though: I lost family in the Holocaust.
 
 AxemRanger  14 Oct 2008 20:45
 Add a Comment
 
 
As repulsive as holocaust deniers are, the answer is no. If thought can be legislated to prevent holocaust denial, what else can be legislated against? Disagreeing with the government? Criticizing criminal corporations? To have free speech, you have to allow ugly speech too.

Besides that, if denying one holocaust is deemed illegal, doesn't that mean denying other holocausts is also illegal? If so, then there are many jews in Israel, AIPAC and the ADL who should be in prison for lobbying the US congress to vote against calling genocide the mass murder of two million Armenians by Turkey in 1910.
 
 K9  13 Oct 2008 18:52
 Add a Comment
 
 
What happened to free speech and opinion? Or does that only count if you don't speak against WW2
 
 caroline28  27 Jul 2008 13:06
 Add a Comment
 
 
No. You should be gassed.
 
 2free  27 Jul 2008 11:34
 1 Comment
 
 Irony makes me smile.

You brightened my day, haha.
by  Snipex
 09 Aug 2008 22:07
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
You can only defeat someone with such thoughts through debate. It's counterproductive to just tell them to 'shut up' and lock them away. Their view will not be changed they will just learn when and where not to express it. If the state can stop everyone speaking out against the norm, then they are in a very powerful position. Anyone who doesn't agree with state policy or state ideology can just be thrown into prison.
 
 Kirsty08  27 Jul 2008 09:36
 Add a Comment
 
 
No not jail just slapped for being an idiot. Hey maybe they should be forced to wear a yellow Star of David patch that says they don’t believe so that everyone would know to avoid them.
 
 finsch  10 Jul 2008 04:57
 Add a Comment
 
 
You can't be forced to believe something
 
 ur_wrong  26 May 2008 02:09
 Add a Comment
 
 
Wow, belief wardens, that's scary.
 
 stever  26 May 2008 01:33
 Add a Comment
 
 
I don't believe people should be sent to jail for not believing in a event in history. That would be ignoring the 'Habeas Corpus' which is the constitutional protection against unlawful imprisonment which we've had for hundreds of years-even before America was founded!
 
 Maggie1  26 May 2008 01:22
 Add a Comment
 
 
I don't think anyone should go to jail for believing in conspiracy theories. That is preposterous .
 
 moreno  26 May 2008 00:19
 Add a Comment
 
 
Its stating a conspiracy theory you believe
its hardly an immoral or violent crime and people should not see jail time for it
 
 JackLC  25 May 2008 23:52
 Add a Comment
 
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
Corporal Punishment Is Bad Because It Shows That People Are Being Treated Different From Others.
Social Services Need To Start Doing A Better Job!
Middle Schoolers Are More Perverted And Rude Than High Schoolers
Euthanasia. Accepted Or Condemned?
Out Of School Suspensions Make No Sense
Zoos Is Imprisonment
Prostitution Should Be Legalised, Regulated And Taxed.
The Gap Between The Classes Is Too Vast
We Should Be Cautious Or Even Rejecting When It Comes To Female Fire Fighters.
Suicide Should Not Be A Criminal Offense.
New Debates
Ghosts Can Communicate With The Living..
PSYCHICS Are Really Getting Messages From The Beyond
The Perfect Partner For You Is The Person Who Loves You Not The Person To Whom You Love
Everyone Shouldn't Be Categorized
Humans Are Awesome
If You Feel Sad Or Depressed, Then That's Your Own Fault.
The Bible Has Outlived Everyone Who Has Ever Denied It's Authenticity. Edit: It's A Metaphor Guys. Detractors...
People Should Be Allowed To Join The Bnp Without Losing Their Jobs
People Are Sadly Misled If They Think Any Political Party Really 'Cares' About Them.
The Charities Don't Really Give Money To Who They Say They Will