» Home » History
Robert E. Lee Was One Of The Greatest Men Who Ever Lived.
General Robert E. Lee - Greatest hero of the history of the United States. And Martin Luther King was also. The Civil war was about STATES RIGHTS not slavery as such. Even Robert E. Lee's enemies......respected his character and nobility.
 Scorpion  13 Aug 2008 22:44
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
My agreement here is slight. Robert E. Lee was not the villain many would have you believe, but not one of the greatest men who ever lived either.
 
 Cons_Lies  14 Aug 2008 03:12
 Add a Comment
 
I respect Robert E Lee, I understand he was acting on principles he considered noble, and I consider him a major historical figure of the US. One of the greatest generals that ever lived - YES. One of the greatest men who ever lived - HARDLY. You're placing him up there in contest with Jesus Christ, Ghandi, Buddha, Confucious, Einstein, etc. He may have been a great military leader but he hardly makes the short list for greatest men who ever lived. Also let's not forget the fact that his side was trying to preserve slavery.
 
 Grenache  14 Aug 2008 14:22
 Add a Comment
 
 
What is the definition of a great man? Some one who helps man kind? Well at this point in time i would probably help man kind and the whole world by killing off 80-85% of the worlds human population as to help stabilize resources. Does that make me a great man?
 
 Smito  14 Aug 2008 04:08
 Add a Comment
 
 
Maybe he was the greatest man who ever lived in the Sates, but frankly thats not saying much.
 
 verum  13 Aug 2008 22:57
 2 Comments
 
 What would you know of American history?
by  Cons_Lies
 14 Aug 2008 03:13
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
The Atomic Bombing Of Hiroshima And Nagasaki Was A Justified And/OR Acceptable Act
John Paul II Demeaned The Catholic Church By Making So Many Saints
The American Revolution Shouldn't Be Considered A True Revolution
Physically Speaking "Survival Of The Fittest" Is Becoming Less And Less Relevant.
People In The Middle Ages Did Not Think The Earth Was Flat.
Hitler Was A Fag.
Robert Kennedy's Death Was The Result Of A Conspiracy
The Second World War Was Not Just Hitler's Fault.
Man Was Made By Apes
Jerusalem Is The Greatest City EVER.
New Debates
The Chicken.. Or The Egg?
Porn Is Good For You And Your Partner.
Meat Is All That Is Needed To Survive.
Gordon Brown Has Lived Forever
The Following Two Pseudo-scientific Terms Should Be Added To All English Lexicons: Heterochromofoliphile...
God Created Man For The Lulz
Britain Is The Best Country In The World
Personhood Is Eternal:
Citizens Of UK Must Be Too Afraid To Speak Up To Their Government. Why Else Would A Supposed Free People...
Ashkenazim Are Descended From Abraham.