» Home » Miscellaneous
People Who Say That Religion Is The Cause Of All The Major Wars In History Are Deluding Themselves
Let's go over a few really big wars. 2003: Iraq War: Caused by a desire to eliminate imaginary WMDs. 1959: Vietman War: Communists and later, hysterical Americans. 1939: World War II: Invasion of Poland by a man who hated Jews. Later, when US entered, caused by Japan bombing Pearl Harbor. 1914: World War 1: Archduke Ferdinand assassinated. 1861: Civil War: Part of USA secedes for the sake of legal slavery. 1775: American Revolution: Caused by rebellion against British tyrants.
 Mark  03 May 2008 22:54
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
Mao Zedong:
Was responsible for the death of millions of Chinese. He regularly meditated on the writings of prominent Atheists.
Josef Stalin:
This time he made it up, was responsible for over 50 million deaths, and suppressed religion.
 
 XieXie  21 May 2008 23:20
 1 Comment
 
 [sarcasm] but i wouldn't like that Because it interferes with my bigoted agenda wah wah wah[/sarcasm] You are exactly right.
by  Mark
 21 May 2008 23:40
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Clearly it's an exaggeration to say that religion is the cause of all major wars in history. It has still been a destabilising force throughout history, though, and the cause of many wars, or a significant enabling influence on them.

Your claim that Hitler "hated religion" is flat-out false. Hitler was a strong religious believer who invoked God continuously throughout his life. There is a debate elsewhere on the site in which I decisively refute the contrary opinion. There is also an article in the Articles section of the site showing the same thing.

Don't underestimate the religious factor in the Cold War. It was apocalyptic Good vs Evil fantasies in America which gave rise to the Cold War and later sustained it and these were nourished in part by the fact that the Soviet Union was dedicated to atheism.

It's absurd to say that the 2003 war was caused by a desire to eliminate WMDs. No one with a clue thinks that Bush & co. Really believed there were WMDs there or that, if he did, it was the main motivation for his invasion. A desire to hit back against Muslims was decisive in lending popular support for Bush's war and thus making it possible, so it fits perfectly into the religious war paradigm.
 
 Hidell  04 May 2008 00:25
 3 Comments
 
 Hitler has stated that Christianity is doubleplusungood because it is "an invention of the Jew" but never mind. I wouldn't be surprised if the guy was mentally ill so he would be contradictory. The Cold War wasn't exactly a war. I'm pretty sure that the Iraq war is for oil.
by  Mark
 04 May 2008 00:42
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Religion may be used as a catalyst, or as something that might get people to fight, but it's almost never religion. Typically it's resources, either natural or territorial.
 
 innomen  03 May 2008 23:09
 Add a Comment
 
Dang did he get his facts wrong

Hitler hated Jews
If u really wanted to make a valid point u would list the death toles for all religious wars and all none religious based wars u would see that there are far more on the deaths on the religious sides
oh don't leave out the crusades!
And if u want to be specific and thorough which you seem to lack the ability.

U could say that most migration from one area to another is for freedom of religion. (Something the catholic church would eliminate today if they could) Then later wars were fought over those lands the only reason the ppl fighting were not one in the first place is because of the religious feuding.

One of the reasons we settled in the Americas was for our freedom of religion. Eventually leading to the Revolution.
Then there is the Spanish revolution. Oh and if you would really like to read facts, pick up the guiness book of world records find the top 10 genocides and count the ones backed by religion. Than make a list post it so i can show you the others that u decided not to count because you didn't know what they were about.

Again the crusades
the Spanish inquisition
WWI
American Revolution
We are fighting in Iraq because Saddam Hussein was a tyrant committing acts of inhumanity. On ppls who

guess what! Didn't have the same religious beliefs as him.
Shiites and the Kurds

Than there is the Tutsi genocide in Rawanda which was started by the Hutus which started as a religious tribal group who felt that the Tutsi's were blasphemous towards their gods.

I am not going to say that religion is the reason wars are casued but ppl with "blind faith" and many do, will follow any cause so long as religion is behind it. And that is why religion, if not directly starts a war, is an accomplice to it.
 
 Evidence  22 May 2008 23:22
 7 Comments
 
 Right, and we all know Stalin was a Russian Orthodox and Mao was converted by missionaries.
by  Mark
 22 May 2008 23:24
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
There have been more wars than just those. Look back further in time and tell me which of those were NOT over religion.
 
 momof3  18 May 2008 20:47
 3 Comments
 
 Ottoman Conquests.
Korean War
Hundred Years War
Thirty Years War
Cold 'War'
Shall I go on? I most certainly can.
by  XieXie
 21 May 2008 23:22
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
1,was a war on terror because some Muslims kill in name of alah
2, mentel yanks (all Christian)
3, Hitler reformatem in gods image,
4 because he was a descendant of the HOLY Roman emporer.
5 they went to war over slaves after Christian men started the movement in the name of god

6 . Ok you got me there...

But all in all every thing comes down to religion one way or another.
 
 muin13  04 May 2008 05:16
 5 Comments
 
 lurn 2 spel!!!

1. Most Muslims do not.
2. What about the atheist yanks?
3. Hitler was a nutacse.
4. Huh?
5. Eh?
6. No, it isn't. What did the American Revolution have to do with religion?
by  Mark
 04 May 2008 17:03
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
A Kamoto Dragon Can Beat A Tiger In A Fight!
Northern Women Are Sexier Than Southern Women
American Idol Show Is Cool
Because Humans Spend So Much Time Indoors, We Have Lost Some Of Our Senses. Such As Predicting Weather...
It's No Fair That You Can't Work More Than 20 Hours A Week In Michigan And You Are Under 18
Some People Stop Posting Under Old Call-signs And Come Back In Under One Or More New Signs To Try Different...
There Is A Purpose Of Life.
There Are Too Many Hypocritical So Called Holy Rollers
It Is Reasonable To Think Satan Exists
Everyone Should Be Able To Write Articles On This Website.
New Debates
The Chicken.. Or The Egg?
Porn Is Good For You And Your Partner.
Meat Is All That Is Needed To Survive.
Gordon Brown Has Lived Forever
The Following Two Pseudo-scientific Terms Should Be Added To All English Lexicons: Heterochromofoliphile...
God Created Man For The Lulz
Britain Is The Best Country In The World
Personhood Is Eternal:
Citizens Of UK Must Be Too Afraid To Speak Up To Their Government. Why Else Would A Supposed Free People...
Ashkenazim Are Descended From Abraham.