» Home » Health
Organ Donation Should Be Compulsory To All U.S. Citizens
I think that Organ donation should be required for all us. Citizens.
 yohomies  12 Feb 2008 02:19
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
Organ donation should be made mandatory, I mean, imagine all the lives that will be saved! After all, what are you going to do with your organs when you die? Can you possible take them with you wherever you do go? Nothing can be a more valuable and precious gift than giving the gift of life! :-)
 
 Kilharu  03 Apr 2008 04:08
 Add a Comment
 
 
I am a corneal transplant patient. I was on the waiting list for nine months for my first eye and three for my second. Mine was not a life-threatening condition; if I had needed a liver or lung, I may have died by then.
My vision went from 20/400 -- almost legally blind -- to 20/70 in one eye. It was a miracle, made possible by an individual’s selfish donation of tissue.
The demand for transplantable tissue far, far exceeds the supply; this is especially true in organs. There are now more than 40 body parts that can be stripped from a cadaver for transplantation.
Based on my experience, I cannot see the logic in any argument (save some religious objections) against deciding to donate tissue. The bottom line, folks, is ya just can’t take it with you. So, yes, I agree donation should be mandatory.
 
 chispa  10 Mar 2008 03:25
 Add a Comment
 
Sounds like you are some kind of volunteer. But some people are not willing to give up their body parts even after they have died.
That is their right.
And a sacred one at that.
 
 keepmindok  23 Sep 2008 08:03
 Add a Comment
 
 
No. They are MY guts and you can't have them.
That's just creepy.
Human beings have dignity: Are NOT a used car-parts-lot.

Go find some other person to gut, and stay out of my way.
 
 Scorpion  15 Jul 2008 01:47
 Add a Comment
 
 
There's an easy way to get people to donate organs.

No giving = No receiving

If you're not on the donor's list, you're not allowed to receive organs either. Let's see how quickly people will change their tunes when that becomes law.

It would, of course, only apply to those over 18, though parents of children who die should be encouraged to donate those organs.
 
 K9  28 May 2008 21:02
 Add a Comment
 
 
It's organ "donation," not just mandatory organ "harvesting," which would be pretty scary. This means people *willingly* give their organs. Others have a right to choose not to, just as they can choose whether to be buried or cremated. What about religious beliefs? Our bodies are much more personal (lol!) than our belongings, and we can write wills to say what's to happen with our belongings.
 
 Chell  10 Mar 2008 03:36
 Add a Comment
 
 
Organ donation is the process by which a person agrees to give any of his organs after his or her death to some other patient who is suffering from such a problem where any of his organs have been damaged and is real need of a donor. Thus with the help of one’s organ someone else is getting cured. Now till this far it was an optional process and it was not compulsory for everyone as not everybody wishes to share his or her organs after their death. Thus somebody used to take the decision in donating the organ whereas somebody used to refuse to donate. In fact there should not be any compulsion to the process as not everybody wants to share as everybody has got the right to decide about their personal issues in such a country like the United States of America.
 
 sudipa  08 Mar 2008 20:52
 Add a Comment
 
 
I believe that each and every person's body is unique and precious, and everyone has the freedom to choose what to do with their organs when they pass. Even though making organ donation compulsory could well save a significant number of more lives, I believe this is still outweighed by each person's freedom to choose, especially with regard to something as precious as their own body; for different reasons, people may well wish to keep their own organs preserved within their own bodies, and they have the full right to do this if they so wish.
 
 jsh4  14 Feb 2008 22:03
 Add a Comment
 
 
No, what if there is a defection with the organ.
 
 -125_  12 Feb 2008 02:55
 Add a Comment
 
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
Embryonic Stem Cell Research Should Be Legalized And Funded By The Government.
People With STDs Should Not Use Public Restrooms.
Smokers Should Get Preferential Treatment On The NHS
People Should Not Take Stalin Drugs To Lower Their Cholesterol
Cannabis Should Be Legalised In The UK
People Choose To Be Hermaphrodites So We Need To Find A Way To Convince Them Otherwise Before They Are...
Medications Such A Lipitor That Are Used To Control High Cholesterol, Actually Do More Damage To The...
Nicotine Apparently Being 3 Or 4 Times More Addictive Than Heroin Makes You Think Twice About Smoking...
All Boys And Men Should Get Circumcised
Good Things Come To Those Who Wait
New Debates
If Homosexuality Comes From Genes, Should The Genes Be "Fixed"?
The Chicken.. Or The Egg?
Porn Is Good For You And Your Partner.
Meat Is All That Is Needed To Survive.
Gordon Brown Has Lived Forever
The Following Two Pseudo-scientific Terms Should Be Added To All English Lexicons: Heterochromofoliphile...
God Created Man For The Lulz
Britain Is The Best Country In The World
Personhood Is Eternal:
Citizens Of UK Must Be Too Afraid To Speak Up To Their Government. Why Else Would A Supposed Free People...