» Home » History
Nations Are Psychotic
Throughout history literally every nation that has at some point become more powerful than the nations around it has eventually talked itself into believing that they are more powerful because they are chosen by god or fate or whatever. Then they figure their neighbors must not be chosen because otherwise why would they be less powerful. And since they’re not chosen it is not only okay but a moral imperative to go take all their stuff and kill a bunch of them. Can anyone think of a nation that resisted this temptation for any appreciable amount of time?
 finsch  24 Jul 2008 17:53
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
I think this is true. Just think of all the great super powerful nations that existed in our ancient world. Egypt, Persia, Greece, Rome, and so many other nations truly thought that they were the chosen people and looked down upon of those countries around them. Its more evident from the ancient world because all the strategic moves, and actions those nations executed was conveniently summed up in a few pages in our history textbooks. Also the fact that Polytheism was what made up their religion may have factored in their greed and "Psychotic" behavior. A great example of this is how the Roman's completely dominated the world, and referred to the Germanic people as barbaric scum. And when the Roman nation ceased to conquer the land around it, and began to crumbled the barbarians took over, and the time period was recorded as the dark ages, as if the unloosen ones prevailed, dark symbolizing evil. This is what has happened over and over with all the powerful nations of their time. And speaking more moderately its the United states' turn to crumble, after all the bad it has caused.
 
 verum  08 Aug 2008 02:12
 Add a Comment
 
 
I use the word psychotic in an attempt to liken the actions of a nation to that of an individual. Can you imagine how a person would look if they behaved as nations do? They would be violently paranoid, radical personality and mood changes, compulsive lying, aggressive behavior, willful intimidation, anger management issues, self destructive urges, trust issues, delusions of grandeur, and finally general misogyny I think that most nations throughout history would have qualified for most of those descriptions at one time or another .
 
 finsch  25 Jul 2008 18:45
 Add a Comment
 
 
I'd agree with the basic principle of what you are stating in this debate. However, I would reiterate the main point is this: "there is usually a man of destiny at the fore-front of everyone of these nations that rise up. This has happened throughout history, too."
 
 joe9  24 Jul 2008 18:42
 Add a Comment
 
Why have you based this debate on psychosis?
I don't think leaders of countries invade their neighbors, because they think they're not the chosen ones.
There could be lots of different reasons.
 
 keepmindok  25 Jul 2008 13:03
 Add a Comment
 
 
There's a grain of truth to your post but I have trouble with the term "psychotic" describing it.

Just like absolute power corrupts absolutely, a nation which finds itself the strongest among it's peers does often find itself exerting that power in some sort of superiority complex over the neighbors. That's not psychotic, it's politics. And their superior powers do not last long once the neighbors get together to tear them down or they corrupt and fragment from within.

The US too will have it's demise (if not already in progress).

And actually I agree with joe9 that charismatic people of power at the center of these nations are major factors in how their power gets used. Just look what happened with 8 years of Bush.
 
 Grenache  25 Jul 2008 12:55
 Add a Comment
 
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
Tea Shaped History
Based On The Bible, Followers Of Christ Should Try To "convert" Non-believers
Jesus May Have Been A Sexual Deviant
The 80s Were The Greatest Decade In History
The Printing-Press Was The Greatest Historical Invention Of All-Time
Santa Is Real!
Martin Luther King Was Assassinated By The US Government
Abraham Lincoln Was The Greatest President Of All Time
John F. Kennedy Was Shot From The Grassy Knoll
Generally Religion Causes Death
New Debates
Are PSYCHICS Really Getting Messages From The Beyond?
Should Everyone Be Catergorized
Does The Government....
Humans Are Awesome
If You Feel Sad Or Depressed, Then That's Your Own Fault.
The Bible Has Outlived Everyone Who Has Ever Denied It's Authenticity.
People Should Be Allowed To Join The Bnp Without Losing Their Jobs
People Are Sadly Misled If They Think Any Political Party Really 'Cares' About Them.
The Charities Don't Really Give Money To Who They Say They Will
We Are Going To Have A Great Depression Or Something Along Those Lines