» Home » Society
Most Christians Make Up Their Own Personal Version Of Christianity
You see this all the time on this site, Christians who think they can pick and choose which of their church's teachings, doctrines or moral strictures they can accept. You get practising gays who just gloss over the fact that the practice of homosexuality is denounced by most major christian churches, people making up their own theology that "Hell is Heaven", others deciding that parts of the Bible are mythical and they don't have to believe in them. There are loads of Christians who engage in pre-marital sex or Catholics who use birth control methods.
 Hidell  29 May 2008 17:56
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
Yes.

And in my opinion, there should be 7 billion different religions: As many as there are humans on this planet.

Religion, should adapt to the Individual.
Not the other way around: The tail wags the dog.
 
 Scorpion  26 Jul 2008 20:31
 Add a Comment
 
 
I agree with the notion, in that the way Christianity is practiced in US is largely very self-autonomous. What you often hear goes something like this: "well my Jesus would never blah, blah" or "my Jesus would always blah, blah, blah" etc. Etc. So really what it turns out to be in US is largely "polytheism", with 100 million different Jesus's running around.
This is one reason the US is really not a Christian culture.
 
 charlee  29 May 2008 22:48
 Add a Comment
 
 
Religion is dogma, man made traditions and beliefs. It needs to be understood as such. Most Christian churches rely on certain portions of the bible, new and old testaments to constitute their religion. That's just the way it is. Few rely solely on the teachings of Christ; in fact most churches worship their religion more than they do their Christ. They worship their book more than they do their savior. They are drawn to their "prophets" more than they are the principles that Christ clearly stated (or at least as was recorded).

Paul was the biggest and one of the first offenders of this. He deviated from the ways of Christ to make it easier for him to proselytize. He knew kosher rules wouldn't fly with the goyem, and he was no big fan of the Jews anyway, so he had some dream that made it okay to eat everything. Yeah right. He knew that pork was a major staple of those he was trying to bring over. He also was the one to really come down on homosexuality. Christ never made any mention of this. But the Christians take stuff from the Old Testament and the letters of Paul and his other writings, and condemn it. It becomes part of their dogma.

I am not quite sure what a "practising gay" is, we are who we are. Not really practicing anything, except my trumpet once in a while. I will say that i had a priest come to my house and ask that my partner and I attend mass. He said that they really want more gay couples to attend mass together. You cannot go very far without seeing a church of some denomination without a pride flag on their sign or window. Also the biggest contingent in the gay pride march would be church groups, countless straight parishioners hoping gay men and women will attend their services. Of course this is Massachusetts.
 
 innomen  29 May 2008 20:25
 2 Comments
 
 As I understand it, the Catholic church and some others accepts homosexuals on the basis that they can't help their own nature, but believes that they should refrain from engaging in homosexual acts, which are sinful. A "practicing gay" therefore, would be one who does not so refrain.
by  Hidell
 29 May 2008 20:43
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Of course. If buybull "literalists" were forced to obey it, most of them would be stoned to death by their own rules.

For those who don't take it literally, they're "salad bar christians", people who pick the parts they like and ignore the parts they don't.

Especially the parts that apply to themselves. Ever notice how many of the rabidly religious quote Leviticus against gays and then ignore every other rule in Leviticus that applies to them?
 
 K9  29 May 2008 19:37
 Add a Comment
 
 
Yes this is definitely true. The Bible is so open to interpretation that it has been read into very deeply by different Christians, and as a result, each Christian tends to have their own personal views, and this has given birth to many different denominations of Christianity. I am also inclined to agree that people pick the parts that suit them and are often so blinded by an idea such as homosexuality is wrong, that they forget the underlying teachings of Jesus (ie. Love thy neighbour). However, as long as Christianity can provide a sound moral framework, I see no problem with variations in people's beliefs.
 
 ibanex_87  29 May 2008 18:58
 1 Comment
 
 There is absolutely nothing wrong with having personal moral view if your conscience is sound. Personally, I don't give a flying crap about homosexuality, but the love thy neighbor approach to that would to discourage gays from being promiscuous, in other words, be a celibate homosexual, which is not a sin. Besides, the sin is gay sex, not a homosexual inclination.
by  Mark
 29 May 2008 19:01
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
That's undeniably true, that's why there are so many Christian denominations. Everyone picks and chooses what they want to believe, even within the same church you'll invariably see a wide range of interpretations of Christian doctrine.
 
 Cephus  29 May 2008 18:43
 Add a Comment
 
 
I agree.
 
 Stranger  29 May 2008 18:15
 Add a Comment
 
 
Of course they do, and I would love to see someone deny it.

The fact that everyone interprets things differently or just picks the parts they like, that sit well with them, just says to me how pointless the whole organized religion thing is.

But I thank their god that they are at least wise enough to do so. If they followed the bible to the word the world would be in an even worse state than it is. Birth control is just one example.
 
 StBalders  29 May 2008 18:10
 6 Comments
 
 This one is fairly obvious. I agree with pretty much everything you have said. Not completely, but...enough.
by  innomen
 29 May 2008 18:21
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Actually, everyone has their own unique version, Christian or atheist or agnostic. You have your beliefs about Christianity, so does everyone else. It IS supposed to be a personal relationship with God and Jesus. As far as birth control goes, that's just responsibility, some churches just make up their own rules, not based on any scriptural basis. The other stuff in the debate isn't worth commenting on.
 
 stever  29 May 2008 19:02
 2 Comments
 
 So why have you disagreed.
by  StBalders
 29 May 2008 19:08
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I knew this was directed to me. Annotated version: You see this all the time on this site, Christians who think they can pick and choose which of their church's teachings, doctrines or moral strictures they can accept.(That's everywhere. They're called "cafeteria Christians) You get practising gays who just gloss over the fact that the practice of homosexuality is denounced by most major christian churches,(Gays can't help it) people making up their own theology that "Hell is Heaven"(I did not make that up! People have believed that for hundreds of years. I took that from Cardinal John Henry Newman.), others deciding that parts of the Bible are mythical and they don't have to believe in them(Some are! Like Jonah!). There are loads of Christians who engage in pre-marital sex or Catholics who use birth control methods.(true.)
 
 Mark  29 May 2008 18:34
 5 Comments
 
 So most Christians don't make up their own version of Christianity? Are you sure? Explain why there are so many different versions/denominations of Christianity then. Have another look over the god debates and you will notice how there are so many different takes on all manner of aspects of your religion. Or you could stay on the defensive and call us all idiots. Please just reply and avoid your annotated versions.
by  StBalders
 29 May 2008 18:52
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
If We Each Tried To Live Life The Way Michael Mccandles Did It Would Change The World For The Better
"Conformity" Is Taking Over America
There Are Not Enough Religions In The World To Go Around
We Are All Really Really Stupid.
"Blue Laws' Are Laws The Cops Do Not Enforce
Technology Is Ruining Our Lives
Theoretically And Please Note That I Am Not Religious....God Did Not Want Adam And Eve To Eat From The...
Police Have Better Things To Spend Their Time On Than The 16 Spurs Fans Shouting Homophobic Abuse At...
Passions Are More Important Than Ambitions
The Answer To Every Question Is BALANCE
New Debates
All Dogs Should Be Aloud In Stores
Porn Industry Now Asking For A Bailout!
It Is OK For Every Lady To Have A Different Body Shape
Kung Fu Is The Best Martial Art In The World
Study In A Good University Is Too Expensive
Zola Was A Very Good Writer
Israel's Attitude Is Right Nowadays
Money Is The Cause Of Wars All Over The World
Facebook Is A Waste Of Time
Learning English Is Enjoyable