» Home » Education
Most Algebra Is Not Necessary For The Lives Of Most People Except When They Enjoy Other's Work Involving Algebra
Isn't it true?
 Stranger  20 Feb 2008 15:56
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
Yea, i don't see how algebra come into everyday life
 
 kitten  09 May 2008 22:32
 Add a Comment
 
 
Sure, but algebra should still be required as a class simply because it develops critical and analytical thinking.
 
 mianastra  30 Apr 2008 01:55
 2 Comments
 
 I can develop such thinking without being forced to suffer through such classes.
by  Stranger
 28 Sep 2008 14:40
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
That's clearly true. Yet that algebra forms the foundation for many of the branches of higher learning which at least some people in the class will no doubt go on to. Your point raises an interesting question. If 80% of the class have no use for it, should they be given something else to learn instead? This, of course, presents the difficulty of how the 20% will be selected and sifted from the 80%. Should the teachers just say to themselves, "Well this guy's obviously an idiot. The best he can hope for is a job in the army or Mickey D's so no algebra for him."

Because this question is so awkward, it is usually just avoided and the entire class is forced to undergo algebra instead. As soon as these selections were made, and pupils of different ability were taught different things, there would be a huge volume of complaints about it. Maybe it would be possible to offer more optional courses though, so pupils and their parents could decide for themselves.
 
 Hidell  21 Feb 2008 13:19
 Add a Comment
 
 
Most of the English, and math you learn in high school, and college you'll never use. It's sad but true, unless you become an instructor, mathematician, or writer.
 
 baconbust  20 Feb 2008 18:26
 Add a Comment
 
 
Most algebra, geometry and calculus taught in high schools certainly will not be used on a daily basis by the vast majority of people. Unless you are planning on getting a university degree in architecture, physics, engineering or, of course, theoretical mathematics, spending hours slaving over algebra assignments will not be useful once you have completed secondary school.

This debate highlights a major problem in most North American schools--the emphasis placed on advanced mathematics is far too strong, especially when compared to the fact that other subjects, such as English literature and history, get the short end of the stick. Yet when it comes to later white collar office work, is it not more important to be able to communicate effectively, to be able to digest a large amount of material--only to extract the key points--and to have the skills needed to analyse documents and situations, than be able to solve elaborate equations?

Unless students plan on going into a field that requires advanced math knowledge, high schools should simply offer them basic accounting courses, which may prove useful when filing tax returns, when investing, or for banking.
 
 mackenzie  20 Feb 2008 17:01
 2 Comments
 
 whats geometry? is it like geography?
by  muin13
 21 Feb 2008 21:24
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
If you subscribe to that belief then you will fail in maths. Algebra has many useful applications in the real world.
 
 ibanex_87  05 May 2008 17:25
 3 Comments
 
 Do I need to know the radius of my pizza before I eat?
by  Stranger
 26 Sep 2008 20:47
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Those who aspire to nothing will achieve nothing.

Most people today are incapable of understanding anything more technical than a two page instruction manual. It's better to know more than you need than need more than you know.

Why else do you think so many people today willingly buy into the idiotic nonsense of creationism? It's because they're not educated enough.

Edit:

To no surprise, the godbots prove my point about ignorance, gleefully following Goerhing's mantra of telling the lie often enough, except it's only they who believe it. Spewing the same garbage doesn't make it true. The godbots have never proven their "god", only their gullibility.
 
 K9  05 May 2008 17:18
 3 Comments
 
 What is nonsensical about the belief that nature was ultimately caused?

And on the main subject: It is wrong to force people to take classes they will not need. Why force high level algebra classes on people like me who won't need such material? I'm indignant about that. It's one of the things I hate most.
by  Stranger
 28 Sep 2008 14:30
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I use algebra in sales and marketing when i project pricing matrices and spending trends. I actually had to brush up a bit for excel.

I use geometry when i do some small building projects at home.
 
 innomen  22 Apr 2008 23:20
 1 Comment
 
 Are you most people?
by  Stranger
 23 Apr 2008 20:03
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Why not learn it? You will regret it when you are older and you apply for a job that requires such knowledge, or you wish to pursue further schooling and require to have a good knowledge of the subject. Also, if you are capable, you minds as well learn it so you are smarter than everyone else who chooses not to learn it.
 
 chilipadi  03 Mar 2008 03:56
 1 Comment
 
 I will never apply for a job that requires me to find a vertex of anything. I KNOW.
To the contrary: I would be smart by not wasting my time on that (if I wasn't forced to do it!)

But since the utterly flawed system of education won't disappear, I must suffer by taking unnecessary classes. Someone must get something out of it: money or something. There is probably greed behind it. Businesses of textbooks certainly benefit from this.
by  Stranger
 28 Sep 2008 14:37
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I think it's well useful
 
 muin13  21 Feb 2008 21:23
 1 Comment
 
 I don't deny that it is useful. I say it is not needed in most people's lives.
by  Stranger
 25 Feb 2008 18:14
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I think that schools teach it for a reason. Some people do use it.
 
 green15  21 Feb 2008 17:23
 1 Comment
 
 Do most need it?
by  Stranger
 28 Sep 2008 14:33
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Engineering. Lots of jobs in that area.
 
 -125_  20 Feb 2008 22:44
 1 Comment
 
 Are most people engineers or things that actually use high level algebra?
by  Stranger
 21 Feb 2008 13:40
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
Banning This Web Site Is Wrong
Band Is AWESOME!!!
Extra Curricular Activities Should Not Be Made Compulsory At School.
The US SHOULD NOT Require HS Students To Take Classes That Will Have Nothing To Do With Their College...
Proficiency Tests Are A Waste Of Time.
Classes Should Be Divided By Gender
Religion Shouldn't Be Enforced!
Schools Encourage The Social Hierarchy