» Home » Music & Entertainment
Magicians Who Reveal How They Pull Off Illusions Are Betraying Their Fellow Magicians
Sure, it's fun to see how a trick was done, but then it's no longer a trick anymore for anyone. You can say quite literally it loses the "magic". Granted small tricks like you might teach a child to do have already been revealed for a long time, but if you reveal every trick then you kill the fun for most everyone.
 Grenache  07 Nov 2008 21:34
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
Hotdog manufacturers never tell people how the hotdog is made. They leave that up to vegetarian documentary producers.
 
 ur_wrong  08 Nov 2008 02:56
 2 Comments
 
 laws and sausages you don't wanna know how they are made;-)


hotdogs are made from hog's anuses.


laws? by lying scumbags in the nasty government.
by  sylverwyld
 08 Nov 2008 03:07
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Well I think you should be banned from the Magic castle!;-))
 
 keepmindok  08 Nov 2008 01:46
 2 Comments
 
 But then again maybe they'd invite me and saw me in half.
by  Grenache
 08 Nov 2008 15:49
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Knowing how the trick is done completely weakens the sense of wonder and awe of the magic. I think the most gratifying part of magic is trying to figure out how it’s done, not being told.
 
 verum  08 Nov 2008 01:31
 Add a Comment
 
 
I agree. I never watch the shows that reveal the tricks. I will at least have respect for the art if they decide the dollar is more important.
 
 Bugman  07 Nov 2008 21:48
 Add a Comment
 
 
Never ask the Lone Ranger to remove his mask.....
 
 sylverwyld  07 Nov 2008 21:41
 1 Comment
 
 Kimosabe!;-)) Hi ho silver away;-))
by  keepmindok
 08 Nov 2008 01:45
Comment
  
Comment
  
They are not betraying anyone. They are giving magic an added dimension and giving the public more to appreciate when seeing magicians do their work. It will also make magicians have to get better and better now that people know what to look for.

I like knowing how the trick is done. That way I can appreciate the magician's skill all the better. To not want to know how it is done and just shiver is wonder is, to me, the desire to be hoodwinked. If you enjoy magic but don't want to know how it is done, you enjoy false awe.

By knowing how it is done, I can enjoy in much greater depth the magician's skill at sleight of hand and subterfuge and can intelligently appreciate what they do, rather than just enjoy being bamboozled.
 
 tinseldove  28 Sep 2009 23:08
 Add a Comment
 
 
I don't necessarily agree that they are betraying their fellow prestidigitators. Maybe they are just forcing them to reach greater levels of their craft by denying them the opportunity to rest on their laurels. Maybe they are just helping magicians to stay humble and remember they are just people who practice deception for entertainment sake. Those who expose the secrets are also using magic for entertainment sake, though in a new way.
 
 kkcoyne  08 Nov 2008 20:15
 Add a Comment
 
 
I never got magic. No matter the illusion, you know it's only an illusion. How they did it is probably more interesting than the trick itself.
 
 2free  08 Nov 2008 01:49
 Add a Comment
 
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
The First Silent Hill Movie Was More Amusing Than Scary!
Mylie Cyrus Has Done Nothing Worth A Billion Dollars.
TV Shows Seriously Mislead The Public
The New Wanda Sykes Commedy Show Late On Saturday Nights Is Pretty Funny
Bugs Bunny Is Young.
LOUIS Griffan Is A Cooler Mom Than Marge Simpson
Summer Girl By Stereos Is Awesome!
T.i. Is Sexier Then Chris Brown
Beaker And Dr. Bunsen Are The Best Muppets
Heath Ledger's Tragic Death Lead To Batman - Dark Knight Being Over-rated.
New Debates
Can Anything Be Considered Art? What IS The Definition Of Art?
For And Against Should Provide A Link To The List Of Words The Censor Won't Let Us Use. They Can Require...
Students Should Learn A Physical Trade To Graduate Highschool~
Biblical Views Regarding Women Are Utterly Outdated And Should Be Ignored.
Planned Parenthood Is A Bad Thought
The Single Most Effective Action America Could Take To Reduce The Problem With Illegal Immigration Would...
Grey Is The Best Fashion-Color:
You Always Have A Choice
Cocks Are Better Than Hens!
America Will Not Have The Grandeur That Rome Once Had.