» Home » Politics
Legalized Prostitution Has Been Shown To Fail Miserably In Other Countries.
Prostitution in Sweden was such a failure that it was banned in 1999. With legalized prostitution, rape went UP. Prostitution is legal in Holland, and it is causing so much damage, they are considering making prostitution illegal. Rape went up 2530 percent since prostitution was legalized there. No country has benefited from legalizing prostitution. Instead, it brings in hordes of men looking for sex for sale—not only from prostitutes but from impressionable little boys and girls. You can restrict prostitution, but you cannot restrict the kind of predatory men who come to that city looking for sex for sale.
 tinseldove  25 Jan 2009 08:49
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
It so sad that children have to be a part of this debate because of sick men and women who violate the world's most precious commodity.
 
 menhim1967  27 Jan 2009 04:35
 Add a Comment
 
 
Legalize it but clean it up a lot better women that are prostitutes should be tested and should pay taxes for there jobs just as every one else. Also make it a designated area or building for prostitutes such as a business
 
 roadrunner  27 Jan 2009 03:48
 Add a Comment
 
 
The topic of...has it failed in other countries...the stats speak for themselves.
 
 created  26 Jan 2009 19:06
 Add a Comment
 
 
Generally I believe in letting people choose how to live their own lives so I'm not really against prostitution. However, anytime a country, city, neighborhood, or even a single building become associated with sex or drugs it draws the dredge of society to it. Sometimes being that attraction may be the lesser of evils (i.e. You believe people will engage in the behavior anyway so it might as well be contained to a zone) but quite often communities find it spills over to areas they especially don't want it, or attract a degree of depravity or crime or complications they didn't expect.

So I'm not saying end legalized prostitution in the places it exists now, I'm saying it's no surprise communities that have it struggle with problems, complications, containment, etc. Shoot, even watching the show Cops in Nevada they're always having to deal with the hookers coming into Las Vegas despite the fact it's legal outside of it. You just can't contain legalized prostitution nor the disease or crime complications which flow from it.
 
 Grenache  25 Jan 2009 12:42
 5 Comments
 
 The experience of Germany shows that you can. Brothel owners need permits. You can control where they set up and where they don't. Yes, they could ignore that and set up illegally. In practice, they won't, however, because it's not worth the grief. The police would take dramatic action against any brothel that tried to set up illegally. The fact that the vast majority of brothels are legal make it easier for them to take action against the few which aren't.

If, within the borders of a single country, you legalise prostitution within one specific area but ban it elsewhere, yes that may create problems. But the problems derive from the fact that you have banned it elsewhere, not legalised it in one specific place.
by  Hidell
 25 Jan 2009 12:52
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
The question is not whether there are problems associated with legalized prostitution but how do those problems compare to areas with illegal prostitution. The fact is that when properly managed legal prostitution can decrease the violence, human trafficking, drug abuse, and social disease epidemics associated with illegal prostitution.
 
 finsch  01 Feb 2009 18:43
 2 Comments
 
 can you cite examples of this?
by  created
 10 Mar 2009 02:29
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
There is one reason that it has failed (if indeed it has) and that is - it isn't legal everywhere. If one place is enlightened enough to legalise the oldest trade whilst surrounding areas don't then it stands to reason that place will be a magnet for a lot of undesirables. It is a bit unfair to then look negatively at that one place in comparison to its neighbours under those circumstances. It would work if all countries and states made it legal.

There is nothing logically that would link legalising prostitution with increased rapes. Quite the reverse should be true.
 
 StBalders  25 Jan 2009 22:06
 3 Comments
 
 I was confused by the rape statics at first as well, but I am assuming that, since rape is a hate crime and not of sexual origin, perhaps rape increases when there is more of a criminal element surrounding the areas where prostitution is legal. I have not checked the stats out yet, hence I have reserved posting a response on the debate. I did notice your comment and a lightbulb went on. I would not have thought of that if you had not made it a new paragraph. It stood out and that made me think.
by  my2cents2u
 25 Jan 2009 22:29
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
You wouldn't think that would happen. I mean, why rape someone when they'll do it voluntarily for a bit of money? And obviously crime rates would go down. I don't agree with prostitution but I do believe in living a life that you choose, and if your dream is to be a hooker, shouldn't you become a hooker? I don't think legalizing prostitution would harm anybody.
 
 bookworm3  25 Jan 2009 21:54
 1 Comment
 
 I keep coming back to this debate and want to post something, but have not found something new to add. I did comment about to StBalders and wanted to state the same to you. Rape is not sexually motivated. If it were, you would be accurate to say that rape would go down. Rape is a hate crime. Rapists do not have an issue with getting sex from the conventional methods. They want to humiliate, hurt and intimidate the victim. The act of paying for sex would not satisfy the rapist. Of course there are different types of rapists as well. They fit into a criminal profile that is based on violence and not on a profile of someone that is not "getting any" . I do not think that there is a direct link in prostitution and rape aside from the possible link of an increase in criminal activity in general. I agree with what both you and StBalders have to say. I just wanted to add in the part about rape because I think it is being misunderstood in general in this debate.
by  my2cents2u
 25 Jan 2009 22:43
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
According to what I have read, it is up, but not due to legalized prostitution. I Copy pasted an article from Sweden reguarding this subject:
According to a new study from the Crime Prevention Council, Brå, it is four times more likely that a known rapist is born abroad, compared to persons born in Sweden. Resident aliens from Algeria, Libya, Morocco and Tunisia dominate the group of rape suspects. According to these statistics, almost half of all perpetrators are immigrants. In Norway and Denmark, we know that non-Western immigrants, which frequently means Muslims, are grossly overrepresented on rape statistics. In Oslo, Norway, immigrants were involved in two out of three rape charges in 2001. The numbers in Denmark were the same, and even higher in the city of Copenhagen with three out of four rape charges. Sweden has a larger immigrant, including Muslim, population than any other country in northern Europe. The numbers there are likely to be at least as bad as with its Scandinavian neighbors. The actual number is thus probably even higher than what the authorities are reporting now, as it doesn’t include second generation immigrants. Lawyer Ann Christine Hjelm, who has investigated violent crimes in Svea high court, found that 85 per cent of the convicted rapists were born on foreign soil or by foreign parents.
 
 hodver  25 Jan 2009 14:40
 4 Comments
 
 They're are brave to actually print the truth. You wouldn't dare say that in the UK, doesn't matter if it is true or not.
by  StBalders
 25 Jan 2009 20:52
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Prostitution is legal in Germany and causes no problems. There was a colourful brothel - complete with big lovehearts painted on the walls - outside of the place where I used to work there. It didn't cause any of the problems you are describing.

On the contrary, legalising prostitution solves most of the problems prostitution otherwise creates. The prostitutes themselves can be forced to undergo tests for diseases every so often. If they have difficulties with their customers, they can contact the police just like any normal citizen. If they are sick or unable to work, they can get help from the state just like any normal citizen. And they pay their taxes, just like any normal citizen.

And the idea that only sinister, deviant men use prostitutes for sex is naive. I could see them pulling up to the brothel in their cars and parking outside. They seemed just like any ordinary person you could meet in the street.

All countries should legalise prostitution.
 
 Hidell  25 Jan 2009 11:10
 6 Comments
 
 Not according Sweden. They had to make it illegal because it caused so much sex trafficking and rape. Rape in Sweden became very high during it and lessened when it was made illegal again. Though some men who buy sex are not deviant, it would cause an enormous influx of men are are. it is really bad news for everyone.
by  tinseldove
 25 Jan 2009 11:57
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
Parking Fines. The New Laws Spell Chaos
Britain's Should Be Worried That Politicians Have Steered Us On A Course That Has Allowed Immigration,...
Detention Without Trial Has Proved To Be A Dangerous Precedent.
The Current Fear Is Neither Global Warming Nor The Coming Ice Age.
There Are More Liberals On This Site
The American People Should Allow Their Children To Stay Home From School On Sept 8th. President Obama...
Gas Prices Come Down Right Before The Election,This Is A Coincidence
Excluding Evidence From A Case, For Whatever Reason, Does Not Mean It Doesn't Exist. All Evidence Should...
Obama Is Not Ready For The Presidency And We, As A Country, Are Not Ready For Him, Or Any Other Black...
The Law Is Too Soft Against People Who Break The Law
New Debates
Porche 911 Turbo Is A Noticable Car On The Streets.
Is It Creul To Leave A Pet At Home (dog)
Is Coke The Best Cola
Is God More Renowned Than Buda!
Should There Be Another Major Event Created Like Christmas.
Is Taco Bell The Best Place To Eat Tacos
Should An Animal Get Introduced To Australia To Kill The Cane Toads.
If You Meet An Alien It Will Suck Out Your Brains.
Chicken Is Nice
Should Scientists Keep Working On The Value Of Pi?