» Home » Health
It Is A Good Idea To Penalise Hospitals Financially For Every Superbug Victim
With the national health service currently at financial crisis point if we fine every hospital for every patient contracting a superbug they will have to find the money by making cutbacks. Policies from both labour and conservative over last 35 years is targeted at closing the NHS, even as I type this we are told that the NHS is sectioned between Ireland, Scotland and England and further fragmented by a lottery for some treatments. How far will Gordon Brown go?
 Lishman  03 Jan 2008 22:27
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
Hospitals are a place where we keep our patients to get medication with utmost hygiene and technicalities so that they get recovery from the diseases that they are suffering from. But nowadays no all hospitals are being attentive in their duties and most often they have proved their carelessness in many things. Many patients and their family members come up with certain issues which clearly tell about the lack of care that the hospital employees have shown on them. Thus it is a very important matter to deal with and it is a very much punishable act made by those careless hospital employees. The hospital authorities should take care of these issues and if they do not then general public should start penalizing the hospitals legally and financially so that they are compelled to take care of such issues.
 
 sudipa  30 Jan 2008 20:46
 Add a Comment
 
 
This would be a good incentive to tackle superbugs.

At the moment the incentive is complicated and rewards NHS trusts for reducing cases compared with last year. This penalises the good trusts that have very few cases and struggle to achieve a reduction against a good record.

A penalty for each superbug victim would be straight forward and not discriminate against the NHS trusts that have already succeeded in reducing their number of infections.
 
 O-Wiseone  07 Jan 2008 04:53
 Add a Comment
 
Superbugs are created by being TOO clean, so I guess if you want to punish the hospitals for being too clean, you can try going to some nasty dirty hospital somewhere and see how you do. Clorox and other disinfectants can kill off all but the superbugs, so they've become rampant and over antibiotics use has broken down your immune system to these superbugs.
 
 stever  13 May 2008 23:59
 1 Comment
 
 Superbugs are infections that have become resistant to antibiotics. The reason for them is the misuse and overuse of antibiotics. Most people take their antibiotic for about half of the prescribed course and stop when they feel better, allowing the bacteria to gain resistance to that antibiotic. Then, there are the people who insist on an antibiotic for every sniffle. They are just so certain that they have a terrible sinus infection, strep throat or some other thing that is going to kill them if left untreated. If doctors would require cultures before prescribing, we could prevent some of these superbugs. These are not actually anything new. Many are simply spread more easily in the hospital because of the ventilation systems and the fact that there are sick people there who do not have healthy immune systems to protect them from infection. The hospitals are not totally to blame. Everyone from patient throught all health establishments has played a role in these superbugs and can take steps to protect themselves. Another issue is the antibiotics being fed to animals for human consumption. We are unwittingly ingesting antibiotics on some level when consuming many foods. To find a way to stop the spread of resistent staph and strep infections, we have to evaluate the way in which we use antibiotics and look for alternatives when there is not a bacterial illness present.
by  my2cents2u
 10 May 2009 07:48
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
If you take the money away then how would you pay for equipment and food and staff, its a ridiculous notion, it would only make matters worse
 
 muin13  21 Feb 2008 23:17
 Add a Comment
 
 
I see where you're coming from, and this would certainly give an incentive to the hospitals to get their act together. However, if those with the most superbug victims were penalised the most financially, this could well make the situation worse; after all, surely it is these very hospitals which need the greatest amount of financial help, in order to overcome the superbug, reducing the number of cases?
 
 jsh4  21 Feb 2008 04:02
 Add a Comment
 
 
If hospitals had to pay money everytime there is a superbug, where would the money go? It would probably be wasted on something pointless. I agree that instead, cleaning should be more effective and probably taken more seriously. Also, if hospitals paid money everytime there was a superbug, there wouldn't be any money left for us to have free health care, meaning that we would probably have to pay for it ourselves which would probably cost a lot of money.
 
 aimee  10 Jan 2008 20:46
 Add a Comment
 
 
I’m not convinced that monetary penalties would necessarily be effective or desirable in tackling the problem. In fact, penalising hospitals in this way would be counter-productive and divert much-needed funds away from front line patient care.

Rather than treating the symptoms, MRSA and the other ‘superbugs’ should be dealt with by putting more money into hospital cleaning, the current lack of which is one of the major causes of outbreaks.

To minimise the risk of financial loss, hospitals would need to screen all non-emergency patients for MRSA etc prior to their admission and place all emergency patients in quarantine. In addition, to further lessen the risk of ‘superbugs’ being brought into hospitals, all visitors would be banned.

Finally, from the inevitable legal standpoint, would the onus be on the hospital to prove the infection was contracted on their premises, or would the patient have to prove this was the case?
 
 vulgaris  10 Jan 2008 10:13
 1 Comment
 
 hi, well said, I agree!
by  uberlovely
 10 Jan 2008 11:53
Comment
  
Comment
  
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
Mexico Is Not A Good Place For A Summer Vacation This Year.
Dark Nail Polish Affects Your Baby
They Should Ban Smoking
If You Want More Healthy Be Non-vegetarian
Not All Foot Types Will Benefit From Orthotic Insoles. Some People Should Not Use Them At All.
Smoking While Pregnant Is Bad For Fetus
Weight Loss By Medicine
We Should Spend More Time In Sun
Alcohol And Tobacco Are The Deadliest Drugs.
Marijuana Should Be Legalized In Place Of Alcohol.
New Debates
Students Should Learn A Physical Trade To Graduate Highschool~
Biblical Views Regarding Women Are Utterly Outdated And Should Be Ignored.
Planned Parenthood Is A Bad Thought
The Single Most Effective Action America Could Take To Reduce The Problem With Illegal Immigration Would...
Grey Is The Best Fashion-Color:
You Always Have A Choice
Cocks Are Better Than Hens!
America Will Not Have The Grandeur That Rome Once Had.
An Oral B Electric Toothbrush Is Better Than An Ordinary Hand Powered Model.
We Can't Allow Texas To Rewrite History.