» Home » Education
Homeschool Is Better Than Public School
This is for a school debate, and by public school I mean both public and private schools.
 Guyman442  22 Apr 2008 17:56
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
I home-schooled my son for several years, and got him way ahead of his public school class....he got the Presidential Honours Certificate sent to his school, given him at his high school graduation, for having graduated in the Top 5% of The Entire United States Graduating lass of 2006. He had one of the highest S.A.T.s in the USA.

Home-schooling? I gave my son a definite edge academically, before I enrolled him into public school for socialization his last few years there. Young people need some socialization.

I have a stack of academic achievement awards from my son's school years.

His freshman year in school, I got an invitation from the Claes Nobel peace prize family, asking my son to join their academic club for specially scholastically achieving students, Honours Society....

He attends college full-time, and works a job part time.

He is taking Engineering.
Aeronautics Engineering.
 
 sylverwyld  05 Nov 2008 04:51
 Add a Comment
 
 
Most kids who are homeschooled are getting a much more superior education than most of those who attend government schools. We would see this plainly if it weren’t for the federal government being too afraid to keep up with our test scores.

SGPGTD = some group of people got together and decided. Decided what you ask? Well “they” whomever “they” is, decided that certain things MUST be learned at a certain age, not sooner, not later. No matter how advanced or behind a child is – what matters is the “standards” that government school advocates think are the one and only means of educating. Homeschoolers tend to be doing a fine job without the need for those words-on-paper a/k/a “standards”. Combined with “political correctness”, it’s the “standards” and the likes of “No Child Left Behind” which has led to the sad state of public education in America. The standards are so low in the South that its no wonder we have schools who will lower standards just to ensure the abilities of their athletes. A homeschool Mom’s standards are way, way higher. (She is often not the religious nut that clueless people claim she is either.) Top that off with the fact that the majority of us know the true value of Art, Music and PE and would never dream of cutting these classes due to lack of funds. We can treat our children like the individuals they are. They will never be just one of the masses who may or may not *get-it* before moving onto the next concept. A homeschool parent KNOWS when the child doesn’t “get it”. That is why *I* am the one who is best suited to teach my child – NOT SGPGTD.

Children in traditional government schools do not get to learn a lot of History because certain parts of it are not in-line with what SGPGTD so school children miss a whole lot of truths. School children are often bounced around from city to city, district to district and try as they may, SGPGTD can not give children a good foundation in Science or History in the elementary schools because of the jumping around only offering bits and pieces of each subject at different times/years. History should be taught chronologically, not in bits and pieces. There is no pattern for the purpose of trying to reason the *why’s* of what those people did and what compelled them to do things the way they did them back then. Those pieces are like a puzzle which never gets completed.

Because of money and liability issues, school children miss out on a lot of Science as well. A good homeschool parent will ensure that her child has access to labs and museums which offer a lot of hands-on learning not found in some school building due to funding issues. Of course, schools do get the occasional field trip but it’s rushed and limited to what driving distance and time restraints will allow for. A homeschooled child often makes learning a part of his/her family vacations. We take hikes in the mountains to learn about different plants and animals. We have over-night field trips to watch nocturnal animals with night-vision glasses at the zoo. We have evening field trips to view the stars using “real” telescopes.

So people please – when you feel the urge to use the word “real” in regards to homeschool – don’t! It just shows lack of forethought.
 
 momof3  05 May 2008 06:04
 Add a Comment
 
 
I was homeschooled for most of my education and I can tell you these things, K9:

1. No way! Most of my teachers when I was in school plowed on with the curriculum no matter whether a student was ahead of it (hint, hint) or falling behind. We didn't learn anything that wasn't on our standardized tests either. It sucked, because we didn't learn science or history or anything.

2. Homeschoolers socialize! I had more friends when I homeschooled than I EVER did in school, and they were better friends, too. Homeschooling groups are everywhere now and they do stuff all the time. Socializing is TOTALLY not an issue for almost any homeschooler and I've never met a single anti-social homeschooler. In fact, any anti-social people I've met went to school!

3. Most school districts now will give their books and lend equipment to homeschoolers (books for individuals and equipment for classes).

About classes: Many homeschooling parents will give classes to other homeschoolers and these students also can learn at their own pace. So many of us go to college earlier and we don't have 'intellectual issues'. Most homeschoolers are smarter and more concerned about IMPORTANT things (i.e. Politics, world events, the environment) than public school kids. Also, children with special needs can get more attention than in a class. We don't get into as much trouble either (ex. Drugs, drinking, premature sexual activity, etc.) and you'll find the suicide rate amongst homeschoolers much lower than amongst public school kids. Schools also force their opinions on kids (ex. The Food Pyramid and other 'nutritional' materials, often donated by special interest groups). It really isn't right. And you know who was homeschooled? John Q. Adams, George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, William H. Harrison, Abraham Lincoln, Theodore Roosevelt, Woodrow Wilson, Grover Cleveland, James Garfield, John Adams, Andrew Jackson, John Tyler, Benjamin Franklin, and FDR. In many schools including Ivy League Universities, homeschoolers are actually more likely to be accepted than public schoolers. They tend to have higher test scores, they tend to have more extracurricular activities, and finally, they tend to have fewer problems with transcripts. Many homeschoolers move on to college for better things. In fact, here is a link to a list of famous homeschoolers

If anyone has a problem they see with homeschooling I have not addressed above, please, bring it to my attention.
 
 veggiefry  28 Apr 2008 14:36
 Add a Comment
 
 
Kids like myself sometimes need the comfort of home, not the pressure of public school life.
(no, I'm not home schooled, but i wish i was.)
 
 im_trumpet  22 Apr 2008 19:59
 4 Comments
 
 No, sorry, you need to deal with reality. The reality is, once you get older, you're going to need to deal with pressure. Hiding from it is foolish.
by  Cephus
 22 Apr 2008 20:26
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I'd rather learn at my house than go to school and be uncomfortable so homeschooling is better than public schools!
 
 HuntinGurl  22 Apr 2008 18:08
 Add a Comment
 
 
Yes- I think learning in your own home where you are comfortable for you to learn in
 
 huntcowboy  22 Apr 2008 17:59
 1 Comment
 
 I couldn't agree more!
by  im_trumpet
 22 Apr 2008 19:59
Comment
  
Comment
  
Public and private is better because it gets you out into the world and it gives you a taste of what the real world is like. Being homeschooled you aren't experiencing what you should be experiencing. I know people who have been homeschooled and went to a public school and they said they liked public school better.
 
 celva_olva  14 Nov 2008 12:37
 Add a Comment
 
 
It is a lot harder to learn social skills when you are homeschooled, and it is very hard to function in today's world without them.
 
 sherbert  05 Nov 2008 04:39
 Add a Comment
 
 
If you're home schooled you don't have the chance to socialize with other kids.
 
 Ms_murder  15 Jun 2008 05:35
 Add a Comment
 
 
No. Homeschool is only for those living in isolated areas.

1. Public school has professional teachers and properly taught subjects.

2. Learning to socialize is part of why children attend school.

3. Schools and school districts have more buying power and can get better equipment, better books, etc.

There is only one reason for "school vouchers" and other attempts to get children, usually from wealthy families, out of the school system.

The goal is to destroy the school system, just as it is to destroy the middle class. The US is becoming a feudal nation of the very rich and the majority as serfs and slaves at the bottom.
 
 K9  22 Apr 2008 20:20
 1 Comment
 
 "Public school has professional teachers and properly taught subjects."

Okay, so can you explain why we have so much failure in today's schools? They teach kids how to take and pass just two tests per year - yet the school kids are failing those tests in record numbers. Homeschoolers are not failing at least one of the very same test (the other one is not required of homeschoolers in GA) - it's too bad that the US government is too afraid to keep track and post our test scores side-by-side in comparison to public and private school students grades.

Many of the more intelligent people on this board would benefit from reading "Dumbing us down: the hidden curriculum of compulsory schooling" By John Taylor Gatto.

"Learning to socialize is part of why children attend school."

Only a child would think that. I bet the teachers (the adults) at your school will tell you that you are there to learn and that being social is just a perk.

"Schools and school districts have more buying power and can get better equipment, better books, etc."

Really? Then why do they scream for more money in defense of the poor job they are doing??? Do you think your library at the local high school has more books than the public library does? True, they are censored the same - but is the quantity the same? I doubt it.

My only "goal" is to educate my children and do a better job than the government schools ever could. Being social and meeting up with other kids to hang out is just a perk of having school finished by lunch-time every day. Some days they will have to wait for their neighbors to get home from school, but most days we can go out and have fun with other homeschoolers long before 3pm. Then there's the many co-op groups that we have to pick from. Some of them offer more social activities than others, but there's always park days, clubs, field trips and other homeschool activities which are designed specifically for the purpose of "socializing". Throwing a little learning in for perks is a good day and time well spent!
by  momof3
 05 May 2008 06:51
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
No way public school is way better
 
 viking435  22 Apr 2008 18:11
 1 Comment
 
 why?
by  im_trumpet
 22 Apr 2008 19:59
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Nope antisocial behavior!!!!!!!!
 
 dapker143  22 Apr 2008 18:02
 2 Comments
 
 Two things.
First; FEW homeschoolers have problems interacting with other children,
Second; What "social behaviors" that grade school children and High school students display will be useful as an adult, in an adult world. The "Socialization" that most public schooled kids show, has nothing whatsoever to do with life as it really exists.
by  jhamm
 28 Apr 2008 15:16
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Honestly i think it is good to have an option but some kids might have intellectual issues later on in life.
 
 melisiwa  22 Apr 2008 18:00
 1 Comment
 
 Some kids DO have "intellectual issues later on in life". That has nothing to do with homeschooling though because they are schooled by the public schools. Haven't you heard the latest news? Our government school children are are way behind intellectually and academically in comparison to kids educated in other developed nations.
by  momof3
 05 May 2008 06:31
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Public school is way better
 
 nick21  22 Apr 2008 17:59
 1 Comment
 
 why? I don't dissagree, I just want to know why.
by  Guyman442
 22 Apr 2008 18:17
Comment
  
Comment
  
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
The US SHOULD NOT Require HS Students To Take Classes That Will Have Nothing To Do With Their College...
Classes Should Be Divided By Gender
GCSE's Should Not Have Coursework
Teachers Do Have Favorites.
Most Algebra Is Not Necessary For The Lives Of Most People Except When They Enjoy Other's Work Involving...
Younger Teachers Are Better
It Is True That Everybody Should At Least Try To Go To College
Mandarin Chinese Should Be Taught In North American Schools Instead Of Spanish