» Home » Miscellaneous
Insults Do Not Defeat Reasoned Arguments
Go ahead, take your cheap shots, I'll enjoy seeing them, but they don't prove anything. As children we first learn to respond to adults with sass and insults and negations because we don't know enough yet to make a good argument. Let's see you repeat that behavior now. But none of us really know the others beyond our anonymous call-signs and posting histories so you can't really know them enough for most personal attacks to be supportable.
 Grenache  22 Oct 2008 23:41
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
If you cant make a decent argument, don't try. Just insulting the other person or their arguments doesn't prove anything other than the fact that you cant come up with a decent argument yourself. If you cant stand the heat, stay out of the kitchen.
 
 mordsith  05 Nov 2008 00:02
 Add a Comment
 
 
It's true, insults do not prove a point. I think people start tossing insults when they're too frustrated to say anything logical to support their point.
 
 SlyOne  25 Oct 2008 05:10
 Add a Comment
 
 
Attacking the person instead of the debate is unnecessary. As a member of the audience or a judge on a panel, I notice those things very quickly. The first one to distance him or herself from the topic by insulting the other will get a negative mark.
 
 athling  24 Oct 2008 03:24
 Add a Comment
 
 
People who don't like losing and and happen to be losing at a debate that require a sense of knowledge or rationale are most likely to start firing insults. They don't prove anything, all they prove is that the other person is right.
 
 kddan  23 Oct 2008 15:49
 Add a Comment
 
 
Insults don't make people change their minds if they know they have good reasons and evidence for their position. They don't prove anything except the stupidity and shallowness of the insulter.
 
 sherbert  23 Oct 2008 05:13
 Add a Comment
 
 
I'd insult you for saying that, but the moderators usually take those down. There's got to be a reason for that.
 
 ur_wrong  23 Oct 2008 01:25
 Add a Comment
 
 
Good point, Grenache. The discipline of good thinking and good argumentation is perhaps a thing of the past, just look at US political debate.
 
 charlee  23 Oct 2008 01:24
 Add a Comment
 
 
I agree with you. Many people do not know how to get their thoughts across, so they get frustrated, and the insults fly. They think this how debating works. An intelligent, mature individual will see the humor in it..Those who insult, etc..cannot
 
 ghost-e  22 Oct 2008 23:50
 Add a Comment
 
 
Insults don't really contribute to an argument. They really don't apply, unless your arguing about whose the better person.
 
 verum  22 Oct 2008 23:47
 Add a Comment
 
Insults do defeat argumants, they do not mean anything twords the debate.
 
 n-stein8_  24 Oct 2008 03:54
 Add a Comment
 
 
Sorry I'm all out of insults today, I might come back tomorrow with some though. It’s a dog eat dog world and sometimes to let yourself be heard you have to dish out the insults. But it should always be a last resort, I only use insults when someone is being unreasonable or they are dishing out insults first.
 
 Andromeda  24 Oct 2008 00:46
 Add a Comment
 
 
Whats your definition of reasoned and insult?? Why can't an insult be a reasoned argument??
 
 Easy_uk  23 Oct 2008 20:28
 7 Comments
 
 Insults are directed at the individual. Reason is directed at the topic at hand.

However, In elections the topic at hand is the individual. Bloodsport
by  Specter87
 23 Oct 2008 20:33
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Are you ready for this? Prepare yourself for the waterworks. Here goes:
Your mother is a terrible cook!!
I know what your thinking, this guy is crossing the line, but sometimes you gotta something about breaking omelets or whatever.
 
 Specter87  23 Oct 2008 03:38
 2 Comments
 
 Ouch, burn. (Thanks, I liked that).

We were talking at work about the news report of the mother who microwaved her baby to death because she was fighting with it's father. Most called her a terrible mother -- but we also pointed out that maybe she was just a terrible cook.

I guess I'm lucky by the time microwaves were invented I was too large to squeeze into one.
by  Grenache
 23 Oct 2008 13:42
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
In Order To Breed Animals You Should Have A License
We Don't Have A Fixed Destiny
Telling The Truth Can Sometimes Be More Painful Than Lying.
Kids Should Not Have Sex In School
Non Human Animals Are Smarter Than Humans
Hikes Are Good For You.
People Who Answer Phones For Companies Should Have To Speak Perfect English!!!
18 Should Be The Legal Age For Everything
If You Idolize Barney, You Will Live An Unhappy Life If You Are Over Fifty, Overweight, And Live In Uzbekistan...
Nobody On This Site Can Stay Focused Enough To Have A Real Debate
New Debates
World Government Is Inevitable.
All Dogs Should Be Allowed In Stores
Porn Industry Now Asking For A Bailout!
It Is OK For Every Lady To Have A Different Body Shape
Kung Fu Is The Best Martial Art In The World
Study In A Good University Is Too Expensive
Zola Was A Very Good Writer
Israel's Attitude Is Right Nowadays
Money Is The Cause Of Wars All Over The World
Facebook Is A Waste Of Time