» Home » Miscellaneous
If The Devil Is God's Enemy, And You Get Sent To Hell For Disobeying God, Then The Devil Should Reward You In Hell Not Torture You - Because You Made A Common Enemy
Seriously, why should someone who upset God be then punished extra severely by the Devil? That makes no sense. You'd think they'd be rewarded in Hell instead; made a knight of the Devil. Unless the Devil still takes orders from God, in which case there's no way the Devil wields free influence over the souls of the living. So which is it? Either the Devil has free will and thus might reward someone, or the Devil is subservient to God and thus really not the source of evil among the living?
 Grenache  30 Nov 2008 16:22
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
That is the logic I used when I created a recent debate about hell being more fun then heaven. It makes sense, and there probably is more freedom in hell as well.
 
 Tromanator  11 Dec 2008 22:34
 Add a Comment
 
 
Satan is the enemy of man - not God
 
 TexasStar  01 Dec 2008 01:30
 1 Comment
 
 Then God wants to watch his friends. Fly with the crows and that.
by  2free
 01 Dec 2008 01:36
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
God is the devil for Christ sake.
 
 2free  01 Dec 2008 01:28
 Add a Comment
 
 
I agree. Why would those who left God be punished by Satan for doing exactly what he wants them to do? Some would say that he does it to cause God suffering, or because he takes pleasure in the regret of mankind, but I find that the Hell described in I, Lucifer is a more logical creation; people who go to Hell have a jolly good time doing whatever they want to do for all eternity because that is the ultimate insult to God: The realisation that we don't need Him to be happy.
 
 Jakers  01 Dec 2008 00:23
 Add a Comment
 
 
In the bible it says to be n hell is o be fully cut off from he love of God, and that's ment to be the real torture. So I guess it well be quite pleasant in hell if you accept satan as the one true god and yeaild to his every whim.
 
 muin13  30 Nov 2008 17:07
 1 Comment
 
 So Satanism works just as well as Christianity? I guess it depends on if enjoying Hell is as good as enjoying Heaven.
by  Quincel
 30 Nov 2008 18:07
Comment
  
Comment
  
Your talking about ideas not actualities. Regardless of whether things are one way or the other, one man's reward is another man's trash?
In other words, if the devil were in the business of going to the trouble of giving things to people, he would probably expect some sort of interminably exaggerated thank you card.
 
 characters  30 Mar 2010 17:16
 Add a Comment
 
 
No. Because you either become in a sense a 'slave to righteousness' in heaven or a slave to sin in hell. God rules hell in a way, hell is not Satan's playground. Hell is meant to punish Satan as much a s the next person.

The slave to righteousness idea doesn't seem so slave like, because the idea is fulfillment on your part to be with God, be the human God originally created you as with glorification without all the repercussions since Adam and Eve. So You willfully behave as a 'slave'. And remember, there might still be a degree of freedom, after all, Lucifer chose to be Satan.
 
 gottfried  22 May 2009 04:25
 Add a Comment
 
 
The devil isn't in charge of Hell, so he doesn't have power there. God is all-powerful, and He is the one that punishes people in Hell.
 
 sherbert  02 Dec 2008 22:40
 Add a Comment
 
 
The devil does not reward or torture anyone in hell. The devil roams the earth ("Job" says it). He's not in hell now, waiting for souls to enter Hades. In the end, he will be in the Lake of fire with all who are disobedient and not forgiven. The Lake of fire is mentioned in Revelation and is called the second death. I think that hell is different than that lake, and that it is a temporary holding place until the end of the age or something.
 
 Stranger  30 Nov 2008 21:57
 Add a Comment
 
 
First of all, nobody knows how hell is really like. Maybe the devil DOES give out rewards, but we don't know it. Or maybe it really is just a horrible fiery pit. We don't know. In the book Dante's Inferno, the devil is said to have absolutely no free will, because free will is actually a gift from God, and he's stuck in a lake of ice and can't move or do anything that he wants to. And since God made hell for the devil and his followers, maybe it's God's "time-out corner" so to speak. The devil's being punished too, so maybe hell has nothing to do with the devil at all. In other words, hell is God's creation and the devil and all who dwell in it are going to be punished. Why would you get rewarded for being bad?
 
 bookworm3  30 Nov 2008 19:25
 Add a Comment
 
 
Ok, I’m just following the internal logic of the old stories here. Maybe he’s just psycho and can’t resist abusing the people he hates so much. But then isn’t the real torture supposed to being out of god’s sight or something like that? So maybe it is all tea and crumpets but it’s awful anyway because god won’t return your phone calls. Or maybe it is like professional wrestling; they talk real big about kicking each others butt, but back stage their all chummy while planning the show for the next night. Or maybe we are all just gods imagination and we are like we are because god is full of neurotic self-loathing as well. In which case hell might just be a therapeutic effort to get rid of god’s issues.
 
 finsch  30 Nov 2008 17:22
 Add a Comment
 
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
Evolution Is Just Another Religion
If A Debate Gets Too Popular, The Moderators Should Remove It
People Should Stop Debating Religion, For It Doesn't Really Matter Which You Belong Too.
Girls From 11+ Try To Be Adults Too Soon
Youtube Changed The World
You Can Believe In God Without A Religion
Rambo Would Defeat Arnold Schwarzenegger In A Fight
The Behemoth Is An Awesome Ride!
If Under 12 Years Of Age, Children Should Not Join YouTube As Members
Cyber Bullying Is So Not Cool..
New Debates
Steven Hawkins Claims There Is No Room For "GOD" In Creation - Is He Right?
"The Wire" Is The Greatest TV Show Of All Time.
It Is Wrong To Worship A God That Allows Hell To Exist
Forandagainst.com Should Have A Neutrual Section For Some Debates.
Www.WeGoLook.com - Robin Smith Is Most Probably The USA's Most Predominent Creative Industrialist Since...
Godfighter Is Stuck On Only One Theme. I Have To Wonder If His Brain Holds Anything More!
The Legal Drinking Age Should Be Raised To 21
Atheism Allows Total Independence And Gives One Incredible Power
Children Shouldn't Worship Religion Until They Are Old Enough To Understand What They Are Worshipping...
The Show 'Best Friends' Should Not Be Canceled