» Home » Health
If Smoking Is Banned In All Public Places, Then So Should Barbecues Be
As burning an average 10 pound bag of charcoal gives off as much smoke and dangerous chemicals as 160 packets of cigarettes, it is a fact that it is far more harmful to inhale barbecue smoke than cigarette smoke. Therefore if cigarette smoking is banned in all public places then so should barbecues.
 Jahwobble  16 Apr 2008 13:25
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
Excuse me how many people do you hear die from barbecue smoke? Your debate is silly and you need to re-think it. Fags are addictive you don't see people running shouting oh god i need to breath some barbecue smoke
 
 xxGINAxx  23 Oct 2008 16:12
 Add a Comment
 
 
Your logic is flawless. We ban smoking because it causes health problems from the smoke. Barbecuing causes health problems from the smoke. There for barbecuing should be banned in any public building like smoking.

Problem is tho that inside barbecuing is rare.
 
 Smito  23 Jun 2008 20:59
 1 Comment
 
 I am talking about people who are calling for smoking to be banned in all public places. Indoors and outdoors.
by  Jahwobble
 14 Jul 2008 16:51
Comment
  
Comment
  
Although I am a smoker and feel banning smoking in the outdoors is ridiculous, I don't feel that exposure to an occasional barbecue is any more harmful to one's health than walking past someone smoking a cigarette in the outdoors. If a group of smokers is congregated near the entrance of a building, I can see a point in the logic of banning smoking in that area, but to ban entire parking lots and other large outdoor areas is becoming a huge frustration to me. I do try to be considerate. I was more considerate, to be honest, before I was told where I could smoke. Now, I have no choice but to light up in areas that it is not allowed in because otherwise, I would not be able to smoke at all in many locations. I do think non-smokers have rights and should not be subjected to second hand smoke wherever possible, however, I also feel smokers have rights as well. We are addicted, not just smoking for pleasure and to torment non-smokers. With that said, banning barbecues would be yet another thing that takes away from our rights. If we are going to ban all unhealthy things and substances that are legal, I suggest processed foods, fast food, high fat content meat and diet foods go as well. That would be ridiculous, but so is banning smoking or barbecues. I understand that people may feel one is only harming themselves with processed foods for example, but people buy these foods for their children who are too young to make informed choices about what to eat and with obesity becoming an epidemic, I think parents should stop feeding their already overweight kids the junk. Should we have a guard at the grocery store weighing the children and removing fattening foods from the carts? There is so much talk of banning this and that. A barbecue may give off enough smoke and chemicals to be dangerous if one were to sit in front of one each and every day, but most people I know barbecue in moderation and during the warm months of the year. Still, it is outdoors and people tend to put the food on, walk away and come back just to check it. Not many people are standing there inhaling the smoke.
 
 my2cents2u  24 Nov 2008 01:37
 Add a Comment
 
 
Alright bbq's cigarettes, what about car exhaust???
 
 moonak  17 May 2008 03:42
 Add a Comment
 
 
This is stupid. I can't respond to incoherent nonsense so instead I will write some nonsense of my own: Gubbel wack flubflub chumple spuzz.
 
 Mark  03 May 2008 23:31
 2 Comments
 
 No, either you are stupid or you didn't read it properly.
by  Jahwobble
 08 May 2008 15:35
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
People smoke all year round whereas barbecues are not a regular occurance. Barbecues, like people have already said, are held out in the fresh air making it less dangerous than a cigarette, which is properly inhaled. Also, everyone finds a barbecue enjoyable, whereas there are quite a few people who find no pleasure whatsoever in smoking a cigarette!
 
 louise23  19 Apr 2008 22:12
 Add a Comment
 
 
Cuz barbecues release all these carcinogens into the air that kill people everyday
 
 Evidence  18 Apr 2008 17:51
 Add a Comment
 
 
Barbecues are out in the open air, but when we talk about banning smoking, we're talking about inside public buildings.
It's wrong to kill or hurt other people just for your pleasure.
 
 im_trumpet  16 Apr 2008 13:37
 1 Comment
 
 I am a smoker and have no issue with smoking inside of public places being banned, but when outside and away from others who do not smoke, I do not feel it is right to make an entire area smoke free. If it were actually done for health reasons, as most places state, I would be more understanding, but these places ban smoking outside of their establishments because of lower insurance premiums. I do not want to smoke. I started smoking at 20 years old and am addicted. I have tried to quit. I spent several hours in the ER with a migraine last night. After hours of not being treated, and unbearable pain, I wanted a cigarette very badly. I was unable to have one because even in my car, it is considered on the property of the hospital. If one of my loved ones were there in a life threatening situation and I wanted a cigarette, I would have to drive off of the hospital grounds to smoke. I do not actually abide by this nonsense. I do, in fact, smoke in my vehicle. They are unable to stop smokers from having a cigarette, but can ask you to put it out if someone working there sees you. I would never presume to smoke by an entrance nor would I sit on a bench where there are non smokers and light up, but I do have some rights. I am not an inconsiderate person. I even go outside to smoke in my own home if I have company that doesn't care to be around cigarette smoke. It is not a huge health risk to have someone 1,000 feet away from you smoking a cigarette in the outdoors. I concede to indoors and even to parts of the outdoors where there are many people around, but there has to be a place where a smoker is permitted to have a cigarette. Most smokers are more frustrated by the loss of any rights, considering that it is legal to smoke tobacco, than they are about trying to be able to smoke wherever they want to smoke. We simply want some area where it is ok to smoke when we need/want a cigarette. No smoker I know wishes to kill or hurt innocent people for their pleasure. In fact, smoking doesn't remain pleasurable. It becomes an addiction which is very strong and harder to beat than a narcotic addiction.
by  my2cents2u
 24 Nov 2008 01:24
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Ah well in a barbecue; 1.It's used for pleasurable food, so people would comment on that. 2.The smoke it lets off isn't actually as deadly as cigarettes because, tobacco doesn't cause the smoke, it's for and charcoal. 3.A barbecue is out in the open air so even if tobacco was used it would not be trapped and inhaled, therefore it would be less hazardous.
To be honest smoking shouldn't be banned either but I won't discuss that.
 
 Keeno  16 Apr 2008 13:30
 Add a Comment
 
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
Smoking Should Not Be Banned In Restaurants Except For Designated Areas
Fetuses Are Alive
Fat People Shouldn't Be Allowed To Have Kids
There IS Help For HIV, But There's No Money In It
The British Crooked Teeth Stereotype Is The Result Of A Lack Of Fluoride
Women Should Be Allowed To Give Birth Alone
BMI (body Mass Index) Is Unrealistic.
Teens That Get Pregnant Should Be Allowed To Get Abortion Without Their Parent's Being Present
Medications Such A Lipitor That Are Used To Control High Cholesterol, Actually Do More Damage To The...
We Should Discourage Use Of Condoms They Make Youth More At Risk Of HIV
New Debates
World Government Is Inevitable.
All Dogs Should Be Allowed In Stores
Porn Industry Now Asking For A Bailout!
It Is OK For Every Lady To Have A Different Body Shape
Kung Fu Is The Best Martial Art In The World
Study In A Good University Is Too Expensive
Zola Was A Very Good Writer
Israel's Attitude Is Right Nowadays
Money Is The Cause Of Wars All Over The World
Facebook Is A Waste Of Time