» Home » Science
I Think It Would Be Irresponsible For Human Kind To Attempt To Colonize Other Planets Unless And Until We Figure Out Our Problems Here.
We are making quite a mess with our home planet would anyone else really want us moving into their neighborhood.
 finsch  08 Jul 2008 23:20
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
I agree with finsch and joe9. We, as a species, have a lot of growing and maturing to do before we will ever be ready to inhabit, or even to visit other worlds.
 
 CoyoteEyes  26 Nov 2008 07:37
 Add a Comment
 
 
Maybe that's why we're stuck on this planet. And we won't be allowed to leave until we've cleaned up all the pollution, and sh*** which has been created.
 
 joe9  09 Jul 2008 10:18
 Add a Comment
 
 
I agree that taking what we have here and will only be successful if we can get passed the problems here. On the other hand, we could take what we have learned here and not do that when starting fresh elsewhere.
 
 curious  08 Jul 2008 23:36
 Add a Comment
 
 
If we took our current problems to another planet we would just trash another world. We need to develop a lifestyle conducive to biodiversity rather than destructive of it.
 
 finsch  08 Jul 2008 23:29
 1 Comment
 
 it would be a fresh start
by  markrjg
 09 Jul 2008 08:10
Comment
  
Comment
  
I'm not too worried about humans wrecking the environment on the planets we know of. The environments on those planets are pretty bad already. Of course, humans could cause the destruction of the solar system by altering planetary environments but I think there's time to figure that one out.

I would be much more concerned with humans killing other beings. Humans kill humans. Until they stop killing each other, they should definitely stay where they are.
 
 justsumguy  03 Aug 2008 18:29
 1 Comment
 
 The point I was going for was more about propagating our current problems into a larger arena. It’s likely that it will never be feasible (logistically and economically) to move an entire planetary population. So whatever colonies exist are going to be stuck in whatever bed they make, so to speak.
by  finsch
 03 Aug 2008 19:20
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
First we solve poverty. Then a killer zombie plague comes up. We solve that. Immediately after, the problem of spontaineus
tidal waves come up. We solve that.
Then the internati- uh-oh, we just got wiped out by a huge solar flare. What a shame.
 
 the_atom  03 Aug 2008 18:17
 Add a Comment
 
 
If you believe humans are destroying this planet (like it would appear you do) then wouldn't it be irresponsible not get off this rock and onto another one ASAP!?
 
 Cons_Lies  16 Jul 2008 18:27
 Add a Comment
 
 
We are indeed making a mess of this planet but I don't see why we shouldn't colonise another. You say other species wouldn't want us moving in on their patch, but given that all planets within colonisable distance are uninhabited, I see no harm in us making as much of a mess on them as we like.

I see where you are coming from, but just like I see no inherent value in a strong environment, I see no inherent value in unpolluted other planets.
 
 Quincel  10 Jul 2008 18:48
 2 Comments
 
 The logistical aspects of moving an entire planetary population would mean that it is likely that most of the people on a colony would have to live with whatever situation was created at the new location.
by  finsch
 10 Jul 2008 20:59
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
The premise of your argument is noble - you don't want us to make the same mess elsewhere like we already do here... The only problem with that is we will never ever 100% finish solving the problems here which means we would be doomed to never leave. If the same standard had been applied in the Old World most of the world would still be fairly isolated cultures and the rate of our technical advancements would have been far lower. Not that that would be all bad, but we need as a civilization to keep trying to move forward.
 
 Grenache  09 Jul 2008 15:30
 Add a Comment
 
 
We will kill ourselves in another 200 years or so anyway so it really doesn't matter.
 
 nath0610  09 Jul 2008 08:40
 1 Comment
 
 we won't if we can colonise other planets.
by  the_atom
 03 Aug 2008 18:11
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
We would learn a lot more about the atmospheric conditions and another life

and also it would give us a new home instead of earth
 
 markrjg  09 Jul 2008 08:09
 Add a Comment
 
 
Colonizing another planet might very well teach us things about living on this one. Additionally, we will never figure out all our problems because new problems inevitably develop. By that logic we would never colonize another planet at all.
 
 OzzieMan  09 Jul 2008 07:28
 Add a Comment
 
 
Sometimes the solution is clear but hard to implement because of rigidities in the system. A tabula rasa may be exactly what's required. Look at the founding of the United States as an example. The system of government was essentially based on the ideas of European philosophers who had written extensively about the flaws inherent in Europe's existing systems of government. They already knew what the answer was, but had no way to implement it because of the power of vested interests. The creation of a new country gave an opportunity to put those ideas into practice.
 
 Hidell  09 Jul 2008 05:50
 1 Comment
 
 Even so, it took us two hundred years to get free and we went on to perpetuate many of the errors of the European colonial powers on the American continent. Even now we struggle with the seductive nature of being one of the world’s great powers. This would have to be a true tabula rasa, a universal commitment to a different ethic of self government.
by  finsch
 09 Jul 2008 06:49
Comment
  
Comment
  
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
The Dictionary Says "God Exists " (Webster)
Cloning Is Crossing An Ethical Line And If So, Can We Never Turn Back.
Science Is Easier To Debate Than Religion.
We Should Use Nuclear Energy
The Theory Of Evolution Does Not Explain Psychological Behaviours
Voov IS Scared Of Evolution
Humankind's Evolution Includes Human Cloning And Soul/mind Transference
Abiogenesis (The Origin Of Life On Earth) Is Completely Irrelevant When Concerning Evolution.
Scientology Is Good
Our Drinking Water Should Be Tested
New Debates
CHESS: It Is Not The Game You Are Playing:
All's Fair In Love And War Is True:
Women Prefer Cyrano De Bergerac To Mr.Perfect:
Everyone, Has A "Type" They Are Attracted To Most:
Stalin Did It For The Lulz
Receive My Exports, Girls, U Know You Want To
They Walk Among Us
It's Over 9000!!!!111 It Is!!!11111@
Do Donkeys Hve Skin???
Glasses Are For Batty Boys