» Home » Politics
The US Democracy Will Finally Collapse
In 1787, Alexander Tyler, a Scottish history professor at the University of Edinburgh , said this about the Athenian Republic : 'A democracy is always temporary in nature; it simply cannot exist as a permanent form of government.' 'A democracy will continue to exist up until the time that voters discover they can vote themselves generous gifts from the public treasury.' 'From that moment on, the majority always vote for the candidates who promise the most benefits from the public treasury, with the result that every democracy will finally collapse due to loose fiscal policy, which is always followed by a dictatorship.'
 LilHulk  02 Mar 2008 15:21
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
Keeping within the context of your post and having history available to us (which we either learn from or not), I have to agree. On the other hand, The United States of America was founded as a Republic and still is to some degree. Many believe that a Republic and a Democracy are the same, but they are mistaken. A return to Americas Constitutional principals, which governs the government and protects the rights of the people, will keep America alive. Otherwise, I envision my country joining its Constitutional heros in death.

There is hope. Not all is lost...
 
 athling  18 Sep 2008 21:24
 Add a Comment
 
 
Every great empire falls, so there is no doubt the USA will. Here are some examples:

Rome
Mongolian
Qin Dynasty
British
Indian
Persian
Greek
Russian
Holy Roman (a.k.a Frankish)
 
 XieXie  26 May 2008 22:45
 Add a Comment
 
 
It probably will, our government is so corrupt right now...
 
 mastermov  26 May 2008 14:43
 12 Comments
 
 Also, the electoral college is a way for corrupt politicians to bribe/threaten the representatives into voting for them. Look at how Bush got into office in 2000.
by  mastermov
 26 May 2008 14:45
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Empires always fall for the same reasons:
(a) they overreach
(b) they run out of money
(c) they collapse in their power structure

Rome: A and b.
England: A and b.
Soviet Union: B.
Catholic cult: A and c.
Nazi Germany: A.
Imperial Japan: A, b.
Mongol empire, the Khans: C.

The US is facing all three. And as for the myth of the US being a democracy, it hasn't been for over 60 years. You're just going through the motions while the wealthy pull the strings.
 
 K9  20 Apr 2008 10:38
 Add a Comment
 
 
History teaches us that no government is perfect or permanent and like all of the great empires of the past the U.S. Will see it has within it the seeds of it's own demise.
 
 openurmind  04 Mar 2008 01:13
 Add a Comment
 
 
It's sad but true... Our nation is definitely on it's way down hill... It's horrible but true
 
 baconbust  03 Mar 2008 00:25
 Add a Comment
 
 
I personally don't know, when I get to be old enough, I think I will move from the U.S. Just about everywhere seems to be going somewhere better than the U.S.
 
 I_Own_Ths  02 Mar 2008 23:11
 Add a Comment
 
Obviously the US will not last until the Earth dies out, however long that will take. The thing is, nobody has come up with a better form of government, and even though there are far left nuts who hate this country and form of government and want to see it destroyed, we will endure. There are far too many of us here who love our freedom and the Constitution which provides for that to let it happen. Take the recent elections, I believe people will wake up when they see how far left into socialism the liberal politicians want to take us. Even here in America a charismatic snake oil salesman can lie his way to the White House. But, we shall endure. To quote Mel Gibson in Braveheart: "FREEDOM!!!!!"
 
 sabrinaguy  06 Jan 2009 21:30
 Add a Comment
 
 
Not while I am alive it won't.
"The pen is mightier than the sword".

Writers are the last gate-keepers.
To hold onto freedom and democracy to the last man.
 
 Scorpion  29 Jul 2008 00:06
 Add a Comment
 
 
Democracy is not the only governmental system that collapses; no one here can name the perfect government system. The democratic system may be perfect in theory, but humans always find a way to destroy it.
 
 Custommade  23 May 2008 04:32
 Add a Comment
 
 
Athens did not have a republic they were a democracy, and America is a republic with a guideline of governance called the Constitution. We in America and England have the longest running and most effective styles of governance ever, any downfall will be far from today.
 
 Nando  21 May 2008 20:02
 Add a Comment
 
 
Well, it's actually a republic. I think that it may ebb and flow in the way it is made up, but for the most part the constitution will remain in tact, and the government will continue. Americans seem to have a great deal of resilience.
 
 innomen  13 Apr 2008 22:31
 Add a Comment
 
 
No, you guys are all being fatalists. History doesn't ensure any outcome. Read David Hume if you're not convinced of that fact.
As Charleton Heston might have said, "the only way you're taking democracy (Heston would've inserted the word "GUN" here) away from me is from my cold dead fist."
Peace y'all!
 
 donphilipe  10 Mar 2008 03:51
 Add a Comment
 
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
Britain Should Adopt Sharia Law
Obama Would Be Able To Handle Presidency
They Should Just Make The 'Bail-Out' Plan 70 Googygillion Dollars. That Way They Could Rescue Wall Street,...
Huckabee Is The Best Republican
This Country Would Be A LOT Better Off If People Stopped Worrying About Who Would Be The "Best President"...
Human Rights Are Being Abused By Asylum Seekers In The UK.
The United States Should Support The Efforts And Struggles Of The Ijaws And The Niger Delta People Of...
Bush Was The Most Authentically American President There Has Ever Been
Illegal Aliens Should Be Permitted To Work In The USA
Congress Shouldn't Waste Time On Baseball
New Debates
Porn Industry Now Asking For A Bailout!
It Is OK For Every Lady To Have A Different Body Shape
Kung Fu Is The Best Martial Art In The World
Study In A Good University Is Too Expensive
Zola Was A Very Good Writer
Israel's Attitude Is Right Nowadays
Money Is The Cause Of Wars All Over The World
Facebook Is A Waste Of Time
Learning English Is Enjoyable
The Arabic People Have More Money