» Home » Miscellaneous
Great Britain Is Being Dragged Down By The United States
They dragged us into the Iraq war, took us into Afghanistan, spell all our words wrong and pronounce them incorrectly, and honestly believe it was them who won the second world war. It started in 1939 not when you gegged in.
 emsuz  18 Apr 2008 10:43
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
Yes, Britain's decision to align itself with America so closely at the end of the Second World War was, in retrospect, profoundly misguided. Churchill had the naive notion of an "empire of the English-speaking peoples". He underestimated American power, and overestimated Britain's. It's clear that many British people derived great psychological satisfaction from the closeness of their country's relationship with America, and that, to a great extent, this compensated for the unravelling of the empire and the loss of prestige and influence this entailed. This was the wrong response, however.

France underwent the same process but responded to it in a different way, by defining itself differently from American and insisting on doing its own thing, becoming a semi-detached member of NATO and working to build up the European Union. In retrospect, I think we can say that France was right and Britain was wrong. Instead of cozying up to America, we should have worked more closely with France to share military technology and integrate our own defence structures.

Even though the current French president, the ridiculous Sarkozy, has disowned many of France's traditional policies and adopted a more British-style approach, he was wrong to do so. France made the right choices and Britain made the wrong ones.
 
 Hidell  19 Apr 2008 12:49
 Add a Comment
 
 
Clearly a well thought out argument.
 
 emsuz  18 Apr 2008 10:45
 2 Comments
 
 I submit for consideration that this argument is 100% against as yet, due to the fact that voting on your own debate should not be considered.
by  phoenix
 18 Apr 2008 15:45
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Thank you so much 4 making us Americans feel so warm and loved and special there, Emsuz.
What a warm welcome into the British family-side of this site :-(
 
 Scorpion  21 Sep 2008 08:21
 Add a Comment
 
 
Well you guys would be the expert on decaying empires, but I would think you would be a little less snarky about it considering your own rather spotted history in that regard. And while it’s true that the contributions of many nations were necessary to win the second world war, you have to admit that if Germany had held off on invading the USSR and America had maintained its isolationists stance then the war would have most likely ended quite differently. So if you feel the UK is going down hill take responsibility for your own country. That’s what I spend every day here in the U.S trying to do and I get pretty fed up with this holier than thou attitude from people whose countries were just as big of a-holes when their countries had the power.
 
 finsch  01 Aug 2008 06:51
 Add a Comment
 
 
Actually, the United States and the USSR together won the Second World War. Britain put up an impressive defence of its own territory, but it obviously could not liberate continental Europe from Hitler, while the French bowed out on day one. As for Afghanistan--Britain is present there because it is a key NATO member and it frankly has a role to play there, just like all NATO member states. Under Sarkozy's much more sensible regime, the French have come to realize that as well.

On the whole, Britain's relationship with the US has been salutary for both sides. Maintaining these transatlantic ties has strengthened the UK's position when it comes to opting out of certain aspects of European integration, including the Schengen Zone, as British politicians can continue to argue that they have other strong political alliances to maintain.

The point about Americans misspelling words (like 'colour') and not pronouncing them properly must be tongue-in-cheek and gave me a good laugh. I don't think that Britons need the services of the Americans when it comes to the bastardization of the English language. Just pick up your "tea" at the local chippy, keep your ears open to the pronunciation and you'll know what I mean.
 
 mackenzie  19 Apr 2008 16:32
 1 Comment
 
 Britain did not just maintain defence of its own territory and was long into Europe before any one came along. The war was won on the backs of dedicated people and is not attributable to anyone nation. Look at the work of the Diggers and Gurkha's and but for one stupid mistake by Churchill and Co. the war would have been over before America and Russia decided to aid the situation. It would also have been over long before had the allies come to the table as Churchill requested and Roosevelt abstained from.

It annoys me when others take it as a glory thing when in fact by their actions and attitude, allowed the war to grow to the magnitude it did and was avoidable.
by  paulallan
 20 Apr 2008 02:13
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Have you ever taken into consideration that your saying and misspelling our word wrong!
The us didn't drag Great Britain into Iraq the country had a decision to make and they chose to go to Iraq. The Us has just as much people going, including my sister and my two brothers
 
 Myrabear00  18 Apr 2008 18:38
 Add a Comment
 
 
Unfortunately the US is having problems and it is affecting the whole world not just the UK. What is needed is a separate and competing system in Europe so that the onus of pricing is not beneficial to one nations greed at the sufferance of the rest of the world, we only have to look at petrol pricing to see the differences in action.

I wont get into the argument on WWII because it is obvious the history is not known properly and is relating to film clips.
 
 paulallan  18 Apr 2008 15:25
 2 Comments
 
 Do you have some special insight into history that i missed at Boston College?
by  innomen
 18 Apr 2008 17:26
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Okay first, had the US not entered WWII it may have continued long enough for the Nazi nuclear program to finish their work, of which they were not all that far. That would have changed everything. Keep in mind Britain was begging the US to enter the war.

Secondly, the UK doesn't bend to anyone. They have showed their independence by not entering the EU. The UK has a pretty good reputation at this point in history of balancing both prudence and strength. In some ways i think that the relationship between the two countries is mutually beneficial especially in offering moderation towards the US and added strength to the UK.
 
 innomen  18 Apr 2008 14:14
 2 Comments
 
 Rubbish. The Soviet Union was rolling over Germany. The Americans had to scramble to occupy bits of territory before the Soviet Union did.
by  Hidell
 19 Apr 2008 12:42
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
Magic Sculpting Sand Is The Best Thing
Gay And Lesbian People Change The Way They Walk And Talk After They Come Out.
Marvel Comics Are Better Than DC.
Increase Funding For PEPFAR
Everybody Should Have A Religion
Nobody On This Site Can Stay Focused Enough To Have A Real Debate
It Is Confusing When The Explanation Of A Debate Contradicts The Title.
The Holy Grail Was Not Mary Magdalene It Was A Cup
Guys Find Tattoos And Piercings Attractive On A Woman
If A Tree Crashes To The Ground, But No One And Nothing Is Around To Hear It, It Still Makes A Sound
New Debates
CHESS: It Is Not The Game You Are Playing:
All's Fair In Love And War Is True:
Women Prefer Cyrano De Bergerac To Mr.Perfect:
Everyone, Has A "Type" They Are Attracted To Most:
Stalin Did It For The Lulz
Receive My Exports, Girls, U Know You Want To
They Walk Among Us
It's Over 9000!!!!111 It Is!!!11111@
Do Donkeys Hve Skin???
Glasses Are For Batty Boys