» Home » Education
Electronic Devices In Schools. The Teachers Should Be Held To The Same Standard To Keep There Electronic Devices Away As Well
I think they should...what about you??
 timmercj  25 Jan 2008 03:22
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
Well thats true teaches should put away all electronics and including theirs
 
 reyk123  09 Mar 2010 17:08
 Add a Comment
 
 
Teacher s honestly have no real reason to have electronics at school. And if they do, then they should be locked up until AFTER school is over...why do we get an argument but they can use their electronics any time of the day!
 
 BTDE-Vicky  20 Jun 2008 02:28
 Add a Comment
 
 
I think that either the teachers should follow the same rules or they should have the rules changed.
 
 wallaceg12  21 May 2008 20:05
 Add a Comment
 
 
I agree . Why is it that we cant have them but teachers can answer theirs during Class or have theirs on ?
 
 Katie92  16 Apr 2008 02:37
 Add a Comment
 
 
I agree that teachers should have the same rule with electronic devices as the students do. Same with dress codes. It is very unprofessional for a teacher to have a cell phone or an ipod out during school hours. Students should be allowed to have their devices but to have them turned on during school, unless they are granted to do so. But teachers should really do the same, if they expect to be a good role model.
 
 alex34  04 Feb 2008 02:20
 1 Comment
 
 Agreed
by  1andonly
 08 Feb 2008 03:02
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I think that teachers should turn their cell phones off.I do know that teachers are the more responsible party,but it is not fair that we half to turn off our cell phones and teachers don't
 
 guyfat  31 Jan 2008 23:23
 1 Comment
 
 Thank you.I am not a man,this is a debate room not a chat room.I am not trying to be rude.
by  dogs
 01 Feb 2008 22:37
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I think that teachers should turn their cell phones off.I do know that teachers are the more responsible party,but it is not fair that we half to turn off are cell phones and teachers don't.My statement stays standing.
 
 dogs  31 Jan 2008 00:50
 3 Comments
 
 you rule man!!!
by  guyfat
 31 Jan 2008 23:24
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Schools are the place where students come to get the education and to be getting disciplined as well. Electronic devices like mobile phones, radios should always be kept away. And this rules and regulation should be abide by the students and teachers both. If the electronic device carried by a student can make the disturbance to study, it can be applicable to the teachers also. A single loud ring tone can be enough to disturb the ambience of a school where the silence is much required. Therefore teachers along with the students should be stated strictly not to carry the electronic devices as school is not the right place for using these. If school teaches the discipline to the students, it is also required from the teachers to maintain this.
 
 sudipa  30 Jan 2008 21:05
 Add a Comment
 
 
If the teacher has cell phones and devices etc. They will be breaking there own laws so they should have the punishment just as we get it
 
 bobbyjm  30 Jan 2008 01:23
 Add a Comment
 
 
Yes, there is the matter of an emergency, but I believe teachers should follow their own set rule. I believe this because, the teacher is supposedly the role model of the class, and if he/she is not setting an example of following set rules, than how can he/she expect for her/his students to follow that particular rule. Now referring to the matter of emergency. There is also the option of the off and on switch. In an emergency, teachers can just turn on their phone to use it. I agree to this resolution.
 
 ValerieC  28 Jan 2008 22:22
 Add a Comment
 
 
I agree. Like other people have said, it wouldn't be setting a good example if teachers banned children from using phones and then went on to use one themselves.

Rules that are set should also be followed by the person who set them, otherwise it is unfair. Teachers ban children from using phones because it will interrupt the lesson and prevent children from learning, but the same thing would happen if teachers were allowed to use phones, so the rules must apply to everyone.
 
 louise23  28 Jan 2008 18:07
 4 Comments
 
 How do you define "use"? We are defining it as the cell is on ready to receive calls but not necessarily to place calls or to initiate text
by  HMSdebate
 28 Jan 2008 19:32
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
A good teacher will always follow his/her own set rules. If a teacher prohibits students from using a cell phone in the classroom, then turns around and uses one herself, then she is not setting a good example of following the rules. Teachers should not be allowed to use cell phones in the classroom. If a teacher wants to use a cell phone, then she should do it out of student’ sight. No one has the right to interrupt a class for a telephone call, including the teacher. Therefore, I agree. If a teacher prohibits her students from using a cell phone in the classroom, then she should also refrain from using a cell phone. You cannot enforce rules, if you do not follow them yourself.
 
 Flash  25 Jan 2008 17:54
 1 Comment
 
 I've never seen a teacher with a cell phone out in the middle of class. Ever.
No teacher I have ever had has ever answered a call in the middle of class. I have had a few whose phone rang, but they turned it off and continued to teach.
by  The_Alex
 02 Feb 2008 02:50
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
The reason why cell phones and other electronic gadgets are not allowed in the classroom is because they are distracting and adversely affect the learning process. Now if the teachers continue to use these devices in class what lesson are they giving out to the students? The students are lead to believe that just because teachers are in a position of authority they can do what they tell the students not to do.

Cell phones are equally distracting for teachers in fact they maybe a little more distracting because if the teacher will get busy with his/her cell phone the students will be left with nothing to do while in the case of students using these devices only one or two of them will be losing out.
 
 Twilight  25 Jan 2008 12:43
 Add a Comment
 
 
A teacher is a hypocrite if she demands no cell phones in her classroom, then proceeds to user hers. I agree.
 
 Dhaopac  25 Jan 2008 06:02
 Add a Comment
 
This statement presupposes some sort of equality of rights between teachers and students. Don't feel bad this is a common mistake of teenagers. The fact is the teachers are allowed to do whatever they think is appropriate while you, the student, have to do whatever you are told is appropriate. Way of the world kid, and there is good reason for it.
 
 finsch  17 Mar 2009 16:38
 Add a Comment
 
 
In all honesty, some teachers have a right to use electronics such as cell phones, etc. Some teachers have kids in school, and if that teachers' kids need to be picked up, RIGHT AWAY, teachers should be allowed to use their cell phones.
 
 AxemRanger  15 Oct 2008 15:33
 Add a Comment
 
 
Teachers are adults. When children reach adulthood, they can be treated as adults too.
 
 momof3  19 May 2008 03:06
 1 Comment
 
 But don't teachers say themselves that they are going to treat us like the young adults that we are? That seems kind of contradictory to me.
by  AxemRanger
 15 Oct 2008 15:30
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
No, I believe that teachers need to have access to their cell phones for emergency causes unless they abuse their freedom and slow the process of learning or distract their own students. Students, I believe, also have the right to have access to their phones in case of emergency or contacts with someone (such as colleges) that are in different time zones, but again they should not distract their own learning or others' as well.
 
 mianastra  30 Apr 2008 01:14
 Add a Comment
 
 
The main problems with students in schools having electronic devices is distraction, and theft. Unless the device is slowing the teachers progress in teaching their class, it should be allowed.
 
 Snipex  22 Feb 2008 18:07
 1 Comment
 
 So, a teacher answering their cell-phone is not a distraction?
by  wallaceg12
 21 May 2008 20:02
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I'm against this because teachers should get this opportunity to use electronics in school, because they've been through school.
 
 Gbeau12  15 Feb 2008 22:09
 Add a Comment
 
 
I agree with Alex. I'm a high school student also and maybe the people posting on this website are out of high school but nobody turns off their phones. Texting is a guaranteed occurrence in most classrooms. If there is an emergency, you will either get a silent call, check your phone, and then ask to go to the bathroom. (to listen to your voice mail) or you will read a text about it.

I think Alex's argument on if there is an intruder in the building is convincing. There are definitely times where I would not want to be caught in a situation where the adult did not have a cell phone when we needed one. However I do believe that maybe for argument's sake, in most instances, the teacher should just be reached at her extension # classroom telephone.
 
 rmc031  01 Feb 2008 22:51
 1 Comment
 
 Yes, I agree. The teacher's personal cell phone should be a last resort. I mean, you don't see the secretary in the front office call your teacher personally when he/she is needed, right? The classroom telephone or PA is always the first to be used.
by  The_Alex
 01 Feb 2008 22:54
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I'm a high school student, and I am still against it. Teachers need to be able to use their phones in an emergency. Now, I'm not saying they can go and whip 'em out in the middle of class to answer a call, but they need to at least have access to them in case of an emergency. They are the responsible party. Besides - since I am a student and I see it every single day in school - no one turns their phones off during the day, anyway. Most people just put them on vibrate and text each other in class. You have no right to complain.

The reason students should not have electronic devices on is this: In the event of an emergency - say an unidentified man with a gun comes onto the campus - the teacher, the responsible party, must have control, and if all of the students took out their phones and all called someone different, then complete and total chaos would ensue and it would put the students and the faculty in even more danger. If the teacher could keep order amongst the students and have a structured plan to get out of or avoid the danger, then things would go much more smoothly.

I am not against students POSSESSING electronic equipment, but I do not believe they should be allowed to be on during the school day. If the kid needs a ride home after school, then that is different.
 
 The_Alex  31 Jan 2008 23:36
 3 Comments
 
 then so should students!! u might say that its for emergency but there are phones around. you expect the students to use those phones so why cant they??
by  timmercj
 01 Feb 2008 00:15
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I'm against it because a teacher should have the right to use a cell phone in case of an emergency to contact someone
 
 bobbilly  29 Jan 2008 22:33
 1 Comment
 
 So should a student. Schools are sometimes not as reliable with contacting parents, and they're definitely not as understanding as they used to be.
by  alex34
 04 Feb 2008 02:22
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
We believe that teachers are the responsible party in the classroom, therefore in emergency situations a cell phone would be another way for the teacher to communicate with the administration in situations where the intercom may become inoperable.
 
 HMSdebate  28 Jan 2008 19:25
 8 Comments
 
 I understand your point of view.
by  ValerieC
 28 Jan 2008 22:23
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I don't agree.
 
 Fromwithin  27 Jan 2008 22:20
 Add a Comment
 
 
No, teachers are an authority and should be respected. If they have a phone it shouldn't matter they are an adult. Children need to respect that.
 
 baconbust  25 Jan 2008 22:55
 Add a Comment
 
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
Children Should Have Homework
The Written Word When Understood And Comprehended As The Author Meant It To Be, Is Far More Powerful...
Required Classes Should Not Have Fees.
There Should Be A Larger Range Of Lessons A Student In A Secondary School Can Learn.
English Secondary Schools Are Becoming More Like American High Schools.
School Should Be A Bit Later On In The Morning So You Are Not Tired And You Are Ready To Go To Schoo...
Homework Is A Waste Of Time
Jews Make The Best Subjects For Psychological Eperimenting In A Debate.
Computer Should Replace Teachers
We Have Stunted Children's Learning By Becoming Lazy With Our Language
New Debates
We Can't Allow Texas To Rewrite History.
The Most Famous Religious Texts In Human History Were Not Written Directly By God
If A New Messiah Appeared Today With A Message And Claimed To Replace Jesus & Mohammad & All Others And...
The Devil Is Not A Red Beast With Horns Walking With Impunity Through Flames In Hell And Surrounded By...
God Is Not An Old White Man With A Beard Sitting On A Throne In A Solid Gold Kingdom Up In The Clouds...
Every Once In A While Everyone Should Have A Singsong With Youtube Kareoke And Go Crazy! :D
Should The Drink Drive Limit Be Zero!?
Perhaps It Is Wise For The US And UK To Distance Themselves From Israel
Child Protective Services In Germany Is Abusing Families, Children And Their Government-given Authority...
If America Turns On Israel We Will Lose God's Protection. Obama And Biden's Stance On Building In Jerusalem...