» Home » Politics
The Government Has The Right To Be Involved In Marriage
Okay I'm doing a polygamy debate for class and its due this Thursday i need to know if the constitution mentions anything about marriage for people who are polygamist or even want same sex marriage? Does that give any right for the government to be involved according to the 10th amendment? Please state your reasons i can really use your help I'm very bad at debating
 jmacluva  10 Jun 2008 04:29
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
Traditionally the government has been involved in marriage because in this case the government is protecting the "good of society". In our US government it is often debated whether or not the government should be involved in our personal lives and freedoms. In the case of traditional (one man and one woman) marriage is historically the best way to raise and care for children. Study after study demonstrate that this is the case today.

Therefore, the government, for the common good, has a duty to protect marriage.
 
 charlee  11 Jun 2008 14:17
 Add a Comment
 
 
It matters what you are talking about.
1. Same/sex different/sex marriages Same/race different/race marriages.
2. Parents abusing children by forcing them to have sexual intercourse or physical or mental harassment.

1. I have no problem with this if they want to marry anybody they want more power to them the government is supposed to be separated from the church that says gays are evil and racist agencies that say different races are inferior or evil.

2. This is going against the rights of the children and needs to be stopped. People tend to argue that the children like these things, but that is because they were raised in that kind of environment where they were constantly being hurt or abused and are taught to like it. The government has to step in to stop this or else it will just continue
 
 Smito  10 Jun 2008 04:44
 Add a Comment
 
A US Supreme Court decision from 1878 effectively determined that polygamy was not supported by the Constitution. The ruling argued that US authorities and Republican politicians (who had campaigned against both polygamy and slavery in the 1860s) could ban multiple marriage and in doing so, they would not contravene the spirit of religious freedom, mainly because such a ban would be against a concrete practice, rather than a belief. In other words, Americans (like Fundamentalist Mormons) could both believe and openly teach about the sanctity of polygamy without fear of prosecution, but they cannot legally put it into practice.

There is a point of view, however, which maintains that the government should get out of the marriage business altogether, and leave it to churches. Those who do not want a church ceremony and all those who live in a same-sex relationship, which many churches may not support, could simply live together as a common law couple, and enjoy all the legal benefits of those who are married, specifically as they relate to inheritance.
 
 mackenzie  10 Jun 2008 08:38
 Add a Comment
 
 
One of our laws is that being married to more than one person is wrong. Anyone who breaks this law is subject to punishment. Same sex marriage is a different matter. It has never been clearly stated which is why it is up for debate now.
 
 Tepal  10 Jun 2008 04:34
 4 Comments
 
 So basically what your saying is the law says its wrong but not against it? If both women or men who are married to the single other are fine with that and both know about it then i say let them.
by  Smito
 10 Jun 2008 04:46
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
Parking Fines. The New Laws Spell Chaos
It Is Almost Impossible To Be A Genuine Asylum Seeker In Britain
The Public Will Wake Up In Time To Realize Obama's Leading Our Country Into A Far Left Socialist Black...
The U.S Should Not Be In Iraq.
If You Are Valued Enough To Pay The Same Taxes As Everyone Else, You Should Get The Same Opportunities...
The Fundamentals Of The Economy Is Still Strong
The US Elections Are Just A Popularity Contest
America Doesn't Want A Television Star For A President, They Want Someone To Actually Do The Job. Obama...
McCain Is Afraid And Unprepared To Face Obama In A Debate
President Bush Is The Reason For Our Economic Depression
New Debates
People Who Haven't Watched The Movie, Read The Book, Or Heard The Song Shouldn't Criticize The Movie,...
Government Healthcare Good Or Bad
Is Hydrogen Poroxide A Good Ingredien For Experiments Like Elephant Toothpaste.
MacDonalds Should Be Banned
Porche 911 Turbo Is A Noticable Car On The Streets.
If You Meet An Alien It Will Suck Out Your Brains.
Chicken Is Nice
That My Brother Doesn't Have A Dick
That Modern Technology Is A Plague On Human Relationships
Technology Is Tearing Us A Criminal