» Home » History
The Fall Of Catholicism And The Rise Of The Protestantism Gave Rise To The Future Super Powers, But At The Same Time Destroy Good, Holy Society And Cause A Materialistic Society And Cause The Problems Of Today
I'm merely interested ( from a historic point of view) on what people think on this matter and maybe if the could mention other ideas on what lead to are society of today(I'm talking about English society).
 hecker  13 Sep 2008 21:30
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
I think historically that while King Henry the VIII wanted a divorce (because he did in some way really love and care for Catherine of Aragon) that part of the reason for the formation of the Church of England was Anne Bolyn's doing. Her family was pushing Henry as shown by his decision to later behead them (yes he beheaded more with Anne Bolyn then just her). I think that a good society is one that is consentious of others, that it helps to develop people more. In a large way that is part of what the Royal Family does - they set standards (although I can't say they're always good standards, but they do set them). Things such as education, dedication to duty and faithful service can be seen in Henry and (oh bloody hell what's his brother's name - Charles? Hmmph) regardless they've taken more into them in setting the standards that were formed from their mother. In giving something back to those whom choose to see them. They offer up support and I (even as an American) don't see them as people who are out of touch (much like their father).
 
 evilkitty  13 Sep 2008 22:57
 6 Comments
 
 Don't stop there. Might as well continue with the "royals" switching from Catholic to Protestant and back again. Lots of happy times there.
by  justsumguy
 14 Sep 2008 01:02
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
The split of godbots in Europe meant there were two dictatorships instead of one. People who were persecuted in one religion could run away and hide in the other's camp, while the dictators said, "Ha ha, he's on our side now!"

When the catholic cult was solely dominant, it was no different than the Soviets for its murderous behaviour, and the prostate-ents would have been no different, happy to kill millions. It was Martin Luther, the founder of the reformation, who wrote, "The Jews And Their Lies" to promote the murder of Jews.

Free speech, along with social and scientific advancement, only happen in secular societies where no religion or ideology dominates. All social problems that exist today - hate towards women, gays, minorities, other ideologies and ethnicities, rationalized greed/selfishness/war - are perpetrated by religious nutbags of every stripe.
 
 K9  14 Sep 2008 17:51
 2 Comments
 
 All for secularism, but don't think you can blame all social problems on religion. I often feel I am surrounded by bigoted, racist, sexist, homophobic, general intolerance, at work, in the pub, even amongst friends, and the only truly religious people I know, are possibly just friends of my parents, a different generation, who don't seem to hold such backward ideals, it feels to me that we are going the wrong way.
Granted these are not fanatical people.
I grew up in Scotland, where religion has always been a problem, Protestant and Catholic, held onto by what were never really religious people. Just gangs.
by  2free
 14 Sep 2008 19:15
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Not at all and here's why... The Catholic church was the superpower of it's day controlling most of Europe and becoming quite corrupt in its power. It's most questionable and controlling processes were exactly what the Protestants rebelled against. However, EVEN if the Protestants hadn't opposed it and split others would have. Destitute peasants would have rebelled for economic reasons even if not for religious. Islam would have still remained a polar opposite knocking at the Southern door of the empire. Someone would have taken the church on. And even in Italy the abuses of the Pope during the Inquisitions and especially when a Jewish child was stolen and forced to be raised Catholic is why militarily the Italians beat back the Catholic church to remain in the limited space now known as the Vatican. So in many different ways someone would have taken down the Catholic church even if it wasn't the Protestants. Then in terms of your second point (whether it destroyed holy society) I'll point you back to the fact that the Inquisition, the selling of favours, etc., are solid proof the holy society you believe existed back then really did NOT exist. It was corrupt to the core even then.
 
 Grenache  14 Sep 2008 02:46
 4 Comments
 
 ...and I thought I was alone. : )
by  justsumguy
 14 Sep 2008 02:52
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Now that is really funny. The way I read it...the king of England wanted a divorce. The self-proclaimed "church" got a taste of it's own medicine when it wouldn't grant the divorce.

The king of England declared himself the head of the "church". Why not? So then, he granted himself a divorce. Of course, the marriage didn't go too well. Didn't he have her and her brother killed?

And I don't believe that had anything to do with Protestants, unless you consider declaring yourself the head of the church of England being a protest against the "church".

Let's face it..

Just be thankful England and the rest of Europe exists after their great civilized history.

A good, holy society. I can't stop laughing. Would that be the one that would kill and torture those who had different beliefs? Yep. That would be the one.
 
 justsumguy  13 Sep 2008 21:59
 5 Comments
 
 It was not a divorce henry wanted it was annulment, their to different things.

ps: ask if you would like to know what annumlment means.
by  hecker
 26 Sep 2008 20:15
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
Princess Diane Was Not As Good Of A Person As She Was Perceived To Be.
The People Of Britain Trust Winston Churchill
The Armies And Nations Of The Past Had Much More Integrity And Patriotism Than Now Days.
The Civil War Was Not About Slavery, It Should Not Be Taught That Way In Schools Today
Jesus Is God.
The Printing-Press Was The Greatest Historical Invention Of All-Time
Churchill Was As Bad As Hitler
Malcom X Was Better Than Dr.king
Shakespeare Is The Biggest Fraud In History
Jesus Made Predictions Which Didn't Come True, Thus Proving He Wasn't Divine
New Debates
Gordon Brown Is Not The Prime Minister, MC Hammer Is
Christmas Is The Time For Binge Drinking
The Souf Will Rise Again!!!!!!!111
When You Ain't Got Nothing You Ain't Got Nothing At All!...;-)
Farcry 2 Is One Of The Best Games Around
The Government Need To Dissolve The Federal Reserve And Start The Silver Standard.
Serj Tankian Is A Terrible Singer
The World Needs "Have Nots".
That The State Of Utah Mandate A Comprehensive Recycling Program For All Government Sponsored Agencie...
Professional Wrestling Is Real