» Home » Health
Depression Is Not A Mental Illness.
It is a feeling... Next they'll be telling you that boredom is a mental illness...
 SlyOne  10 Nov 2008 01:21
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
That's just an excuse.
 
 ur_wrong  10 Nov 2008 23:34
 Add a Comment
 
 
Clinical depression is an illness. It is also a mental illness. There are varying degrees of clinical depression and there are also varying treatments of clinical depression. I continue to use the word clinical in front of the word depression because I want to make the point that there is a difference between people who are feeling a normal period of sadness that will go away without treatment and people who are disabled due to a major illness and are not able to live a normal or healthy life unless they are treated. It is sad that you have such a misconception of a serious health crisis. Clinical depression robs one that suffers from it of a normal life. These people may have feelings of low self esteem, guilt, hopelessness, sadness, thoughts of death, weight gain or loss, sleep too much or too little, find no joy in things they once loved to do, lose interest in sex and experience aches and pains that are not explained by another underlying condition. There are other symptoms, but you can check them out if you google depression. I have suffered from a major depressive episode. I also suffered from anxiety and panic attacks. These, thankfully, were related to hormonal problems and have gone away since I had a hysterectomy due to a painful condition. Some of the medications used to treat the condition (endometriosis) worsened my depression and suffering. I also work in the medical field. I have worked in the mental health field. I have read many books on mental health. I am close to someone who serves on a Mental Health Task Force in our community. The fact is that, for many, help is not available. People like you continue to make that problem a reality. It is not only clinical depression that people need to raise awareness of. Mental illness, as a whole, is still misunderstood and misdiagnosed. Lives are lost. Untreated mental illness increases crime and is a contributing factor to drug addiction. People with nowhere to turn, self medicate. These people, use recreational drugs and alcohol because they are not able to get the proper treatment. In turn, the illness worsens.

There is a difference in feeling sad and in being diagnosed with clinical depression. Further, situational depression, can escalate into a major clinical depression if the situation is not remedied and goes on for a long period of time. For the majority of people who have a period of sadness, the situation changes or they adapt to the change and the symptoms go away. For others, the sadness does not go away and they slip further into a clinical depression. This is all due to chemical responses in our bodies. Medications are chemicals. These chemicals have the ability to help people go on to live a happy and productive life once again. For some, it is a lifelong endeavor. For others, it is transient. I also want to make it clear that medications used to treat depression are not all the same. They are also not "happy" pills. There is no "high" from taking an antidepressant. Serotonin is a neurotransmitter. People who do not make enough naturally, benefit from medications that block the reabsorption of serotonin so that it is left at a higher level in their brain. The SSRI medications are believed to work this way. There are other types of antidepressants, but I do not think you want a chemistry lesson here. I just wanted to offer some proof that, for some people, there is a need for medication and that they are, indeed, suffering from an illness. It is not in their minds or something they can will away. It is treatable and people need to open their minds and grasp the concept that the human body is complex and, thus, there are times that modern medicine is necessary to assist in a better quality of life.
 
 my2cents2u  26 Jan 2009 15:53
 3 Comments
 
 I'm sure you could have made the point without pointing fingers at "people like you.''
by  SlyOne
 26 Jan 2009 16:02
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
A simple cold can become pneumonia, and a case of the blues can become a serious case of clinical depression. It's a continuum.
 
 kkcoyne  11 Nov 2008 22:20
 Add a Comment
 
 
It's a chemical imbalance in the brain, thus a mental illness.
 
 yu_yevin  11 Nov 2008 22:15
 Add a Comment
 
 
I've lived with a parent who was most likely clinically depressed and later a lover who was actually diagnosed as clinically depressed. I'll grant that there's a fine line which gets crossed at some point. It may start as a feeling, a bad run of luck, but there are indeed some people in which the condition has a wholistic effect, their body and mind perpetuate or repeat the depression and it literally becomes a physical sickness. And I like MaYbCaKe's point that it relates to serotonin in the brain.

But yeah, there are some who through the rarity of the occurance or the mildness or the short duration of it really have no more than just a feeling of depression. Meanwhile there are others in whom the body exhibits measurable metrics which can objectively prove that yes biologically something is wrong.

On the flipside, is the opposite of Depression a mental illness? Euphoria? Manic behavior? Same situation. It can be just a feeling, but in some cases the body systems can actually prove something deeper is at work than just a feeling.
 
 Grenache  10 Nov 2008 16:30
 Add a Comment
 
 
Depression can be a mental illness or a symptom of a mental illness or a symptom of systemic illness or just a sign it’s time to make some changes in your life.
 
 finsch  10 Nov 2008 13:40
 Add a Comment
 
 
Depression must be a mental illness as it is connected to low serotonin in your brain, hence the mental part =)
 
 MaYbCaKe  10 Nov 2008 10:35
 Add a Comment
 
 
Depression is a mental illness
 
 ACR6407405  10 Nov 2008 05:36
 Add a Comment
 
 
Your confusing sadness with depression. If your having a bad day some might say, "Oh I'm just depressed today." The reality of it is that this person is just sad and will bounce back when their environment changes. If this person felt like this for a few months regardless of environmental factors then this person would be considered sick. I've had both depression and sadness and I know there is a difference. I'm glad that you've posted this topic. It means that you don't know the difference and that you are a "happy".
 
 Specter87  10 Nov 2008 01:38
 5 Comments
 
 Well have you ever had other feelings (lets say happiness) for long periods of time? Would you then consider that a sickness?
by  SlyOne
 10 Nov 2008 01:40
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
All Women Should Get Breast Enlargements Past The Age Of 30.
The Life Expectancy For People Is Getting Better (now)
Swine Flu Was Caused By A Pig
Vicaden Should Be Free
Pimple Creams Don't Work
Doctors, Nurses, And Pharmacists Should Be Drug Tested
Living Longer Is Worse!
Germs Are Good For Us.
Everyone In North America Should Have To Learn How To Levitate.
Laughter Is The Best Medicine
New Debates
MacDonalds Should Be Banned
Porche 911 Turbo Is A Noticable Car On The Streets.
If You Meet An Alien It Will Suck Out Your Brains.
Chicken Is Nice
That My Brother Doesn't Have A Dick
That Modern Technology Is A Plague On Human Relationships
Technology Is Tearing Us A Criminal
Technology Is Tearing Us A Part
Diet Coke And Mentos Is One Of The Best Experiments.
Vegetarians Are Not As Well Balanced As Normal People.