» Home » Health
Cruel To Be Kind
Obese people should be banned from fast food outlets in the same way that it is illegal in the UK to be drunk in a bar.
 vulgaris  29 Jan 2008 16:22
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
Yes Yes Yes. The Germans proved during the war that if people were not fed they lost weight see pictures of Belsen,.
 
 tyronet  01 May 2008 18:38
 2 Comments
 
 ...that's because they're feeding off of their own body fat right? not sure i don't rember health class to well, but it is very very unhealthy, as i quote a move that's been stuck in my head, that's like being the smartest kid with downsyndrome
by  jezhicka
 15 Jul 2008 07:13
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
I agree i think that if you are over a certain weight then you should only be able to go to McDonald's like once every 2 days
 
 crossout  17 Apr 2008 23:58
 Add a Comment
 
 
In today’s world certain relevant health issues are cropping up in such a way that serious precautions are needed to be taken in order to maintain proper health. One such issue is obesity and obese people should not be encouraged to avail fast foods. If any how they are not able to control themselves then the step should be taken from the other way round by restricting the fast food outlets for these obese people. Though it sounds cruel but it is extremely needed for people suffering from obesity because in turn it will help them. Sometimes it is required to be strict on certain points to ensure the healthy and better living of a person and for one must understand that he or she needs to sacrifice certain things from life because those things are leading them towards a devastating end.
 
 sudipa  08 Mar 2008 20:46
 Add a Comment
 
 
It is kind of harsh, but is it not for their own good? Are we not helping to improve their condition of living by not allowing them access to that which creates the problem in the first place? I believe the first step should be for the food industry to be a little more mindful of what it puts out as far as nutrition goes, but it is also the responsibility of the consumer to eat properly. If they do not, then I feel it is the duty - the responsibility - of the society in which the person lives to take a degree of control for them and assist them. Obesity is a serious problem for many people around the world, and should be dealt with as such. By depriving them of that which causes the problem, we will be in effect helping to increase their health, if only passively.
 
 The_Alex  01 Feb 2008 01:48
 Add a Comment
 
 
Great that England has laws against being drunk even in a bar. I wish my country had laws about drinking in public or in the presence of children.

No, absolutely NO, no country should pass a law against obesity of any weight. Being over 135 pounds for women and 178 for men is the disease of obesity. That's probably more than half of the people of the world.
 
 best4write  30 Jan 2008 07:33
 1 Comment
 
 I agree with you argument, though I believe you are wrong when you say that “Being over 135 pounds for women and 178 for men is the disease of obesity.” One must take into consideration that bone density is different depending upon different ethnic groups and one cannot base a weight limit for All people! Plus what is important is being Healthy not the amount your weight.
by  Kilharu
 03 Apr 2008 04:02
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
I think all fast food should be banned, it is ridiculous that people will sit there and say obese people should be banned from entering a fast food Establishment when there are people who eat this food who are not obese, but what is to stop them becoming>? Soon no one would be allowed to eat fast food as they are obese.
 
 spakrme  09 Aug 2008 19:44
 Add a Comment
 
 
Obesity is based on the body fat percentage on a person. Even a fairly skinny person can have high body fat and be considered obese. Though you have ignorantly targeted the people who you see as overweight, and in a free country where we have the right to choose where we eat it would be hypocritical to ban any type of person from a restaurant.
Now back to the obese thing, do you know that most skinny girls in schools are obese. Because of their intake of fatty foods and substances, are you saying that these skinny people should also be banned, for technically they are obese. Or are you purposely discriminating against a group of people whose metabolism may not digest and use up fat as quickly.
I don't even think you fully thought this through before you posted it, discrimination against the bigger people more than the skinny even though they can both be obese is wrong.
Use a different term and rephrase this intelligently.
 
 shycrazyc  28 Jul 2008 20:38
 3 Comments
 
 Not all people are ugly fat, just mostly.

rare exceptions? Queen Latifah.
by  Scorpion
 28 Jul 2008 20:42
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Do you know how far i had to scroll down to get to write a comment??? Nice job I'm guessing everyone covered this topic nicely XD
 
 jezhicka  15 Jul 2008 07:14
 Add a Comment
 
 
We should not ban fat people from fast food restaurants. Eating is a human right, and we should not deny that right, even to fat people.
 
 Mark  30 Apr 2008 21:21
 1 Comment
 
 I agree. its all about rights. and respect. and tolerance. and kindness.
by  Scorpion
 28 Jul 2008 20:43
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
No if they need to loose weight they should have self control. That is like saying the churches that serve wine shouldn't serve wine anymore because there is an alcoholic in their congregation. That alcoholic could choose not to have the wine and the church could have grape juice or some juice for the ppl who don't want wine.
 
 celva_olva  29 Apr 2008 16:42
 Add a Comment
 
 
That's nothing but discrimination...so now we moved from color to weight size? Makes no sense! Plus then they should dan skinny people from weight loss places and drunks from the liquor store. That's just ludicrous
 
 ambercol  07 Mar 2008 15:21
 1 Comment
 
 then eventually, they would BAN ALL OF US DEBATE ADDICTS TOO lol lol at this entire subject now ;-)
by  Scorpion
 28 Aug 2008 06:38
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
You can't force someone to be healthy. Would you? The parallel to drunkenness is erroneous because drunkenness is temporary while obesity lasts long, even until death. It is hard to lose weight with habits, heredity and time. It is comparatively and relatively easier for someone to not get drunk next time they drink.
 
 Stranger  27 Feb 2008 14:44
 Add a Comment
 
 
Every human being any shape or form, language or look has human rights there for if some1 chooses to be obese then its up to them and they may choose where they eat or drink.

If someone would like to lose wait we shouldn't leave it to them selves we should educate them and help them lose the weight until they are satisfied.

I am only 15, in year 11and perfectly fit but when i was in year 7 i was bullyed 6 months strait for the way i looked and because i was fat and i know how it feels!
 
 03Thompson  27 Feb 2008 13:49
 Add a Comment
 
 
No they shouldn't! It is their lives, therefore they are entitled to do whatever they like. It would be very unfair to ban obese people from eating in fast food outlets. It isn't the same as drinking alcohol. Alcohol causes bad behaviour, obesity doesn't.

Some people cannot help the fact that they are overweight and it would be extremely upsetting and unfair if we separated them from skinnier people. Overweight people should not be treated differently.

Banning an obese person from a fast food restaurant is pointless. It doesn't stop them from purchasing fatty food elsewhere. It's their lives and it's up to them.
 
 louise23  31 Jan 2008 14:32
 Add a Comment
 
 
In the constitution it states that were free and no one controls us at all
 
 bobbyjm  30 Jan 2008 23:15
 Add a Comment
 
 
No one has a right to decide what obese people should or should not do. If they want to eat in a fast food restaurant, then they should have every right to eat there. Obese people do not harm anyone. If they do harm, it is to themselves for eating at fast food places. Many people cannot help the fact that they are overweight. Other health related issues cause some obesity and sometimes, it is even hereditary. So, I believe that it is wrong to ban a person from a fast food restaurant simply because they are overweight.
 
 Professor  30 Jan 2008 14:06
 Add a Comment
 
 
I'm FOR being fat, drunk, and happy.
 
 wrldmggt69  30 Jan 2008 11:14
 Add a Comment
 
 
Excellent debate! "In the same way that it is illegal in the UK to be drunk in a bar", this may be the law, but its certainly not enforced.
 
 Smiley  30 Jan 2008 09:37
 Add a Comment
 
 
We can continue to promote good health and anti-McDonalds (sincerely, that place is evil), but in the end, it's up to you to decide to eat fast food or not. We should require restaurants to list calories and fat right next to the item, which would hopefully reduce the number of eaters, but we don't obtain the right to ban them from eating it.
 
 TyWhyHiTy  30 Jan 2008 02:55
 Add a Comment
 
 
Eating is fun that's y I'm so skinny
 
 bobbilly  29 Jan 2008 23:02
 Add a Comment
 
 
No. Freedom of choice should be respected, even when the choice is unhelpful, unhealthy and may in the end lead to fatality. Passing a law such as the one you propose would lead to ludicrous scenarios in which young, often not particularly well-educated counter staff were asked to make off-the-cuff judgements about how overweight a prospective customer was, and whether or not they should be considered obese. This would lead, at best, to offence and distress and, at worst, to violent anger.

Even if implemented, the law would do no good. I'm sure that obese people would find a way to get the food they want, whether by asking relatives to do their shopping for them, or by eating other kinds of food.

To even begin to think about justifying this kind of law, you would have to demonstrate a massively strong correlation between obesity and the consumption of fast food.
 
 Hidell  29 Jan 2008 21:16
 Add a Comment
 
 
I totally disagree. Everyone should be allowed to eat at a fast food restaurant regardless of their weight. Many people are not obese because they want to be. It is an illness that sometimes is out of the person’s control. Obesity not only occurs as a result of eating too much, it is also something that is hereditary or caused by conditions such hyperthyroidism or hypothyroidism. There are several reasons why a person is obese, but being obese should not exclude someone from eating what they want to eat, where they want to eat it. Obese people have the same rights as thin people.
 
 BullDog  29 Jan 2008 19:34
 Add a Comment
 
 
No, and your not supposed to serve intoxicated people in U.S. Bars even though they still do. If someone's fat it's their body, who cares as long as they are happy.
 
 baconbust  29 Jan 2008 18:43
 Add a Comment
 
 
This type of "tough love" approach (if we can even call it that) probably would not be very helpful to people who are obese. Imagine what type of mental health issues may arise if people were banned from restaurants, simply based on their weight. While many who are obese could certainly improve on their situation if they subscribed to a healthier diet and more exercise, others are obese for reasons largely beyond their control.

Being obese is essentially a disability and I don't think that anyone today would propose similar punitive measures for the disabled. Additionally, we cannot compare being drunk in a bar to being fat when ordering a super-sized meal at a fast-food chain. Being drunk is associated with disorderly and potentially threatening conduct, while simply being obese is obviously not. Other clients are not normally inconvenienced in any serious way by someone who is overweight. People should only be banned from public and commercial establishments if they pose a risk to others. People who are obese obviously don't fit the bill.
 
 mackenzie  29 Jan 2008 17:21
 1 Comment
 
 You can compare alcholism to over eating. It's called Nervosa, it's a disease that make people eat constantly. Alcoholism is an addiction and for some people over eating is an addiction.
by  baconbust
 29 Jan 2008 18:45
Comment
  
Comment
  
Sign In / Sign Up