» Home » Politics
Big Oil Is Responsible For High Prices At The Pump.
I am interested in the responses to this topic because I don't think it is being debated honestly by our politicians or in the media.
 Cons_Lies  27 Jun 2008 04:46
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
We also print money out of thin air, with nothing to back it up, therefore increasing the money supply used to buy oil to infinite levels, while oil itself is a finite commodity. Big oil might like this idea, but they don't run the Treasury or the Federal Reserve.
 
 grokit  20 Aug 2008 00:37
 Add a Comment
 
 
Oil profit margins have not increased (about 10%, like most large companies and industries). Oil profits are at record levels because 10% of $4 is a lot more than 10% of $1.

Increases are due to taxes, politics, speculation, and energy market manipulation. Also, increasing demands to use crude oil for things other than gasoline.
 
 JRL  27 Jun 2008 14:01
 Add a Comment
 
 
It is important to note in this debate that the big oil companies average about a 9% profit margin on each gallon of gas sold in the US. The average tax on a gallon of gas ranges from 45-50% per gallon. The rest goes to the costs of drilling for oil, refining it, and shipping a finished product to the pump.
In other words, Big Oil only sees about $2 per gallon, and of that only about 18 cents is profit. Is Big Oil responsible for high prices at the pump? No.
Big Government is. Now, I would have no issue with a gas tax, but when you consider income tax, sin tax, estate tax, property tax, social security, medicare/medicaid, and all the other tax-for-the-hell-of-it taxes levied on American consumers by the Government at local, state, and federal levels, you can't help but wonder what their profits are.
Do I get upset because Exxon profited $10B in a month? Sure, but not because they shouldn't. It upsets me because I'm jealous! That's a lot of money I could do cool things with!
Now, do the math. If Big Oil is seeing about $2 per gallon, that means that Big Gov't is also seeing about $2 per gallon. I understand the break down of what happens with the Big Oil share, but I never hear anything about what happens with the Big Gov't share. Why?
A 9% profit margin seems pretty fair to me. I can think of plenty of other businesses that do much better than that. I am not convinced that Big Oil is the issue here.
I would like to see both McCain and Obama discuss this aspect of the "crisis at the pumps".
 
 Cons_Lies  27 Jun 2008 05:10
 2 Comments
 
 I am slightly surprised by your viewpoint, specifically the subjective preference of business to government. Personally I would rather the government made $2 than oil firms, because the government will spend that money of schemes which will likely benefit me (or if not me personally, a citizen) whereas oil firms will not. You may not know exactly where the $2 goes (although government spending probably is described in the annual budget, it is in the UK) but can you not assume it is somewhere beneficial for you, the citizen?
by  Quincel
 27 Jun 2008 16:24
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
When I Think Of An American, I Think They're All Elitist Like Bush.
Obama Would Be Able To Handle Presidency
Animal Experiments Are One Of The Greatest Evils Of Our Time
Obama Has No Idea How To Improve The Economy At This Urgent Time But Senator Clinton Already Knows How...
Gas Prices Are Too High.
Teachers Should Be Tested For Drugs
Obama Is Being Targeted By The Media Because Of The Race
The Godbot Got Herself Killed
There Is Too Much Complaining And Not Enough Solutions Coming From The Democrats
People Should Respect The Current President Whether They Like Him/her Or Not.
New Debates
Your Computer Occurred In Nature.
Drugs Should Be Legal.
There Are No Gays In Iran
Some People Said Love Is Wicked, How Far It Is Rue
Religious Believers Should Be Subject To A Special Tax, The Proceeds Of Which Could Be Used To Compensate...
The Three Greatest Lies, Evolution, Atheism, And The Cheque Is In The Mail
The Advertisement: ''God Doesn't Exist Enjoy Yourself !'' Shouldn't Be Plastered On The Side Of London...
S Club 7 Is Garbage Forever!
The World Is One Big Lie!
Real Madrid Has Got A Lot Of Potential Players