» Home » Politics
Another Terrorist Attack Would Help McCain Win
McCain's adviser, Charlie Black, said this in an interview. He later apologised and McCain himself disowned his remarks. Do you think McCain's image as a hawk on national security issues would give the advantage if another attack took place?
 Hidell  24 Jun 2008 13:31
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
Such an attack would have boosted McCain's chances by significant margins, but I am not sure that it would at this point, after Charlie Black's unwise comments. Whenever the nation appears to be under attack from external forces, or if stability and public security are threatened in any way, voters have a tendency to cast ballots for the incumbent party. In this case, of course, the Republicans would stand to benefit. The fact that McCain is seen as a hawk would help him as well, but I also believe that even if an attack were to occur under a more dovish, Democratic president, voters would still favour the incumbent over the challenger in times of great distress.

I remember reading an article last autumn by Charles Krauthammer, who essentially argued this point, even though his prediction turned out to be totally wrong. Krauthammer asserted that since America is at war and because there is still an increased risk of a terrorist attack, Americans (including Democrats) would never vote for a neophyte like Barack Obama, but would choose the candidate who has the most experience and who is seen as having a rough streak. Krauthammer obviously miscalculated the Democratic primary, but the basic core of his argument was sound.
 
 mackenzie  25 Jun 2008 09:15
 1 Comment
 
 Fair point, McCain would benefit partially because of the 'rallying around the flag' effect which aids incumbents regardless of his views.
by  Quincel
 25 Jun 2008 09:54
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
McCain would definetly have an advantage seeing as how he is all about defending America. It would drive home is logo and make people have faith in him. That is all it takes, gaining people's trust and you have it in the bag.
 
 curious  25 Jun 2008 03:57
 Add a Comment
 
 
It was a foolish thing to say, but ultimately true. The right wing of politics is seen as more security conscious and McCain in particular is very publicly hawkish ("Why not stay in Iraq for 100 years", or words to that effect). It is likely that people will see McCain as more competent to defend America, so if America is seen as under threat he will gain support.
 
 Quincel  24 Jun 2008 14:08
 Add a Comment
 
No, it would prove that it is actually not working like they are making it out to be.
 
 moreno  25 Jun 2008 16:27
 Add a Comment
 
 
So you are saying that people should be killed just for someone to win and election
 
 xxbragoxx  25 Jun 2008 00:50
 Add a Comment
 
 
No terrorist attacks have nothing to do with who wins the election so that is not true
 
 dragboy67  24 Jun 2008 15:55
 1 Comment
 
 Really? So then why did Bush's approval ratings skyrocket after 9/11? It was because he was seen as reacting tough and because the attacks prompted a wave of patriotism across the country. If that happens before an election then which candidate will benefit? The one who is seen as most patriotic themselves, and that is also associated with the right wing and with McCain.
by  Quincel
 24 Jun 2008 16:19
Comment
  
Comment
  
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
Good Luck To The Truckers Who Are Protesting About The Crazy Price Of Diesel.
There Will Be Record Low Voter Turn-out In 08'
Obama's Economic Plan Is Better For Many Americans
A Woman President Would Be A Nice Change
Gordon Brown Should Go
The Ukrainian President Yushchenko Is Not An Impostor
Time Would Be Better Spent Doing For Self
Serbia Should Not Be Admitted To The European Union
Ronald Reagan Was A Great President
George W. Bush Was Wrong To Lift The Ban On Domestic Offshore Oil Drilling.
New Debates
Porn Industry Now Asking For A Bailout!
It Is OK For Every Lady To Have A Different Body Shape
Kung Fu Is The Best Martial Art In The World
Study In A Good University Is Too Expensive
Zola Was A Very Good Writer
Israel's Attitude Is Right Nowadays
Money Is The Cause Of Wars All Over The World
Facebook Is A Waste Of Time
Learning English Is Enjoyable
The Arabic People Have More Money