» Home » Politics
An Atheist Could Never Become President Of The USA
US politics are dependent on the vocal minority of religious fundamentalists
 MrFlagg  02 Jul 2008 00:18
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
As things stand now, it's impossible. Hidell is right about the one elected atheist, I believe his name is Pete Stark and he represents Fremont, CA. But nobody knew he was an atheist when he was elected... Nobody bothered to ask about his religion until after he was elected! Statistically, a large number of Congress should be nonbelievers. So either the religious seek power more, or members of Congress lie. Wonder which it is?
 
 OzzieMan  05 Jul 2008 02:39
 Add a Comment
 
 
Personally, I don't think God is a politician, more a dictator, so His relationship with democracy and the American political system reeks of the apparent brainwashed madness of the nation. I can understand why a president can need "God" to carry the weight of his decisions, but to me for politics and religion to interweave is madness, brainwashing, look at Northern Ireland, the majority were prods or tims and had no idea or inclination to the pros and cons of remaining part of the British Isles or joining with the south. Religion touching politics is an affront on democracy, and I agree with Mr.flagg that it will be a long time before we see an American president that is non religious because there are too many mindless religious zealots whos vote could be won just by believing their President was following Gods word.
 
 2free  05 Jul 2008 02:30
 Add a Comment
 
 
This is probably true, but how many countries are there in the world where a fundamentalist Christian could ever become president or prime minister? The number of evangelical Christians is growing in the UK, while attendance at traditional churches is dropping, yet there is virtually no chance that Britons would ever vote for a fundamentalist Christian, no matter how charismatic he/she was, or however compelling his/her policy proposals were. Prejudices exist on all sides.

Atheists probably find it more difficult to win public office in the US than in most other western states, but it's really not very easy for an atheist to occupy the highest position in the land in any Anglo-Saxon country. If we take a look at the UK's prime ministers, almost all have claimed to be Christians. We know of Tony Blair's strong Anglo-Catholic faith, while Gordon Brown frequently refers to his upbringing in the Church of Scotland. John Major is an Anglican, Margaret Thatcher a Methodist, James Callaghan was a Baptist, while Harold Wilson was a Congregationalist. As far as I know, Clement Attlee was Britain's only atheist prime minister.

The situation is very similar in Canada as well, where all prime ministers except one have been practicing Christians. Stephen Harper, the current prime minister, is a member of the Missionary Alliance, while his predecessor, Paul Martin, is a devout Catholic. Jean Chrétien, Brian Mulroney, John Turner, Joe Clark and Pierre Trudeau were all practicing Catholics as well. The only openly agnostic prime minister was the Progressive Conservative Kim Campbell, who referred to herself as a lapsed Anglican.
 
 mackenzie  03 Jul 2008 13:42
 1 Comment
 
 Aye, and Clement gave us the NHS, the war and a wee bit of aitheism doing Gods work maybe?
by  2free
 05 Jul 2008 02:21
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
It may happen but they would have to lie about it to win. For a potential president to admit to being an athiest would be political suicide. Hidell correctly points out that only one man in office is a confirmed Athiest. How sad is that.
 
 StBalders  02 Jul 2008 12:04
 Add a Comment
 
 
Until the religious grow up, probably not, which is sad, but we do have a majority of Americans who are fundamentally irrational.

Kind of explains why the U.S. Is in such a mess right now, doesn't it?
 
 Cephus  02 Jul 2008 07:05
 Add a Comment
 
 
It's sad, but true.
 
 mastermov  02 Jul 2008 02:02
 2 Comments
 
 How many good people will never be able to serve their communities,,,,
by  MrFlagg
 02 Jul 2008 02:04
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Not only could an atheist not become president, it would be virtually impossible for an atheist, at least someone who was openly atheist, to win any elective office. I believe there is only one overt atheist among America's many senators and congressmen, and he represents a district in San Francisco or somewhere like that.

The Washington Post featured the results of a poll not long ago in which a huge number of Americans said they would not vote for an atheist. It seems to be the last publicly acceptable prejudice.
 
 Hidell  02 Jul 2008 00:45
 2 Comments
 
 It would seem you have to ascribe to superstition in order to serve your community. How many excellent people are not able to serve in politics owing to this blindness.
by  MrFlagg
 02 Jul 2008 00:47
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
You are so right man, an atheist would no way be elected because of the strength of Christianity in USA.
 
 chaew  02 Jul 2008 00:36
 2 Comments
 
 Given the hypocrisy of Christians, I guess we should not be surprised. So much for love and forgiveness that was preached by their founder Jesus.
by  MrFlagg
 02 Jul 2008 00:38
Comment
  
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Neither could anybody of any kind of minority group.
 
 Snipex  02 Jul 2008 00:25
 1 Comment
 
 You're probably correct, but there is a chance that the US could have it's first black president, but he still needs to pander to the religious right
by  MrFlagg
 02 Jul 2008 00:27
Comment
  
Comment
  
I would think a lot of people would vote FOR an atheist president. As long as that person didn't totally abolish religion in any way, I myself would be okay with an atheist as a president, as weird as that would feel.
 
 bookworm3  02 Dec 2008 03:00
 Add a Comment
 
 
Ask Bill Gates to run and see how far he would get.
 
 K9  05 Oct 2008 10:31
 Add a Comment
 
 
An atheist can think. How else did they decide to become one?
If a person can think, they can govern.

George Bush has religion: Look how bad he is at the job.

I doubt religion makes one either better or worse at governing.
 
 Scorpion  04 Jul 2008 23:02
 1 Comment
 
 However, that doesn't mean the perception of many Americans won't be clouded by preconceptions.
by  sceptic101
 05 Jul 2008 10:36
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
People who say never are often times proven wrong.
 
 moreno  04 Jul 2008 02:53
 1 Comment
 
 But perhaps not in this case.
by  sceptic101
 05 Jul 2008 10:37
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Why would that surprise anyone. The government has been removing all remant of "God" in buildings, schools and money slowly over time.
 
 Mangadear  02 Jul 2008 13:42
 1 Comment
 
 Yet, superstition is still rife in the US
by  MrFlagg
 02 Jul 2008 13:59
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
If a atheist can prove that hes not out to destroy religion and supports all people i see no reason why people wouldn't vote for him.
 
 Smito  02 Jul 2008 05:39
 Add a Comment
 
 
You're right that it's highly unlikely, but never say never. We've elected Presidents for a wide variety of narrowed reasons - war heroes, actors, etc. If Hillary Clinton came out as atheist during her campaign she would have still had many devoted followers who wanted her in mainly because she's a woman. If Obama did the same he'd still have many followers because of his race. People are motivated to vote based on a variety of single issues and if religion isn't the hot topic one year you could actually end up with the atheist.

But yeah, it's highly highly unlikely.
 
 Grenache  02 Jul 2008 02:47
 Add a Comment
 
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
If Obama Is Elected He Will Live Out His Full Term.
The U.S. Should Be Involved With Georgia Scandal
Few American People Actually Know What The U.S. Constitution Says, And Maybe More Importantly Sometimes,...
If McShame Wins, It Will Mean The Republicans Have Stolen The Election
McCain Is No War Hero.
Obama's "A More Perfect Union" Speech Is Historically Important
David Cameron Is A Bag Of Hot Air And Definitely Not The Right Man For The Job Just Because Conservative...
We Wouldn't Have Half The Problems We Do If There Weren't So Many Females In Politics.
HM The Queen Should Disband Parliament And Kick Britannia Back Into Shape.
The Carrot Is Better Than The Stick