» Home » Music & Entertainment
American Idol Is Unfair
It's unfair how all the very talented people get voted off, while all the good looking people go all the way to the finals. This season for example. All the talented people(Syesha Mercado, Carly Smithson, Danny Noreaga, Chikezie, Amanda Overmyer) got out, and all the good looking people(Jason Castro, Brooke White, The Davids) stayed longer
 ghosthunt  06 Jun 2008 16:49
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
It is unfair in a way for the talented people of course. But who is to say who is talented? It is up to America, of who they like and think is good. It is just based on opinion. (also i thought David A. Was a pretty good singer)
 
 kbabyrocks  13 Oct 2008 03:43
 Add a Comment
 
 
American Idol is more than a singing contest. It's a pop star contest and if America prefers good looking pop stars then those people should win.
 
 ur_wrong  26 Aug 2008 03:27
 Add a Comment
 
 
It is fair; America votes and if people don't like good singers and that person is better then the rest that is 2 bad. America votes for who they like not who the better singer is. So in the sense that Americans don't vote for the best that is unfair to the good people. But since America votes we get who everyone likes.
 
 LME  06 Jun 2008 19:41
 Add a Comment
 
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
The Music CD "Much Dance 2008" Rocks!
Rap Music Does More Harm Than Good
Sir Trevor McDonald Was And Still Is Overrated
Reality TV Shows Are Manipulative
A Lot Of Heavy Metal Fans Are Repressed Gays
The Song Paper Planes By M.I.A Is An Awesome Song.
Blue October Is The Best Band.
Clapton Is Immensely Overrated.
Pop Is Better Than Hip-Hop
Serj Tankian Is A Terrible Singer
New Debates
Hockey Is Better Than Ice Hockey.
Is Michael Savage's Opinions Agreeable Or Not
Republicans Are As Responsible For Big Government As Anyone Else.
Why Should Cigerettes Be Illegal
Tobacco Companies Should Be Required To List ALL The Ingredients In Their Products.
Do Ads On T.V. Really Say The Truth?
The Policy For The 'minimum Age To Leave School Being 18' Should Be Bought Forward Earlier.
Zoos Are Not Bad For Animals. Only The Ones That Don't Treat Them With Dignity And Respect Are The Wrong...
Folks Joke About Republicans Being Mean Spirited But It's Basically True.
American Apparel Is Inane, For Only Using So Called Skinny People For There Clothing Line... That's Not...