» Home » Family
A.A., Alcoholics Anonymous Is The Place For Persons With The Disease Of Alcoholism To Find New And Good Friends, Find Support And Help Maintaining Sobriety And To Re-build Their Spiritual Self By Seeking God, As They Understand God.
Some people criticize Alcoholics Anonymous saying it focuses on a fake God, not the God of the Bible, and don't believe that a "drunk" can get sober unless they "become Christians." What do you think about the world wide AA meetings?
 best4write  07 Mar 2008 18:59
                           (What's this?)  Add to Firefox  RSS
Yes. If you require assistance in quitting alcohol, go to AA. If you are capable of quitting alcohol on your own, do so.

Some, are able to stop undesirable addictions by themselves. Depends upon whom one is discussing.

AA is successful for so many substance-addictions. Do whatever it takes.
 
 Scorpion  18 Jul 2008 00:22
 Add a Comment
 
 
The primary purpose of AA is to stay sober and to help others to achieve sobriety. All of the 12 Steps of AA are but suggestions. It works best with a belief in a higher power, but it is not necessary for it to be God, and if it is God, then it is a God of your understanding. The second step is where belief comes in: "Came to believe that a power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity."

It has saved the lives of millions. How is it even possible to say something bad about AA...unless you may have a problem with your drinking and are a little bit defensive about it, or just very ignorant, is beyond me.
 
 innomen  20 Apr 2008 23:08
 Add a Comment
 
 
Alcoholics Anonymous is an association of alcoholics with a worldwide recognition for their aim to help people with this morbid problem called alcoholism. They unite to share their strengths, weaknesses and experience with each other with a motto help themselves as well as others with the same addiction. The sole qualification to join this union is to have the urge of quitting this habit and leading a sober life. There are no restrictions as such for the members like registering, keeping an attendance record or leaking out their social or professional identity which is an example of the fact how they respect an individual’s emotions and privacy. They motivate people by citing examples of former alcoholics who are now devoid of frivolity in front of them. This is surely a praiseworthy selfless contribution to the welfare of our society. So this is an effort worth appreciation and recognition.
 
 sudipa  11 Apr 2008 23:14
 1 Comment
 
 Nicely said.
by  innomen
 21 Apr 2008 14:15
Comment
  
Comment
  
AA is a cult that replaces one addiction with another. Changing an addiction to drugs or alcohol for an addiction to religion is not a solution.

AA also has the worst failure rate for "treatment" despite its claims. Those who drop out of AA and go back to addiction are not counted as "failures"; AA lies about its numbers in the same way as those who claimed prayer cured disease.

Recovery from addiction always coe the same way: Through accepting personal responsibility and through medical treatment. AA offers neither.
 
 K9  20 Apr 2008 11:27
 1 Comment
 
 That wrong at every level. There is no more successful program in dealing with the alcoholic. Name one program or group that has had a greater success rate?

Furthermore AA never claims numbers ever it is agains several Traditions (see Twelve Traditions of AA). AA does not wish to engage in any controversy ever. AA also believes in using outside sources for help as well, like medical help. Typically they are then sent back to meetings by the medical help they get.

Every doctor that has the interest of the alcoholic in mind will urge AA on a patient. It has worked when nothing else has.

It is not a cult by the definition of cult. It is a treatment based in spirituality, but not religion. Accepting personal responsibility is a gigantic part of the whole program. You just are so over your head on this one.
by  innomen
 20 Apr 2008 23:04
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
This is one of those debates that leaves no room for the only true way to answer... In the middle - neither good nor bad, for nor against. It just can't be debated.
 
 fusezhun  07 Mar 2008 19:20
 1 Comment
 
 A more controversial or interesting debate would be is AA religious.
by  innomen
 20 Apr 2008 23:28
Comment
  
Comment
  
 
Sign In / Sign Up
 For and Against Recent Activity
Related Debates
The California Supreme Court Ruling To Legalize Same Sex Marriage Proves The Justices Watch Too Much...
Christmas Is A Wonderful Fantastic Absolutely Delectable Time Of The Year!....;-)
Society Are Confused On The Topic Of Tiger Woods Vs 15+ Available Women
Last-Name Identifies A Family-Unit
It Is So Very Very Good To Give Presents At Christmas Time!...;-)
Taking Your Loved Ones For Granted Is One Of The Gravest Mistakes You Can Make:
I'm 19 And My Boyfriend Is 20, We Should Should Start Our Own Family , And We Sure We Can Support A Baby...
Family Is The Most Important Thing
The New Parents Of 2009 Are Different In Their Tastes Than 40 Years Ago:
People Should Wait To Have Kids Until They Are 30.
New Debates
Child Protective Services In Germany Is Abusing Families, Children And Their Government-given Authority...
If America Turns On Israel We Will Lose God's Protection. Obama And Biden's Stance On Building In Jerusalem...
You Definitely Can Not Trust Anyone Or Anything Anyone Says On A Debate Site Unless They Have Concrete...
There Are Not Many Straight Men Left In The World...; )
Percentages (for And Against) Seldom If Ever Reflect The Truth About Anything, General Elections For...
Only Morons Think Bands Of The Past And Present Weren't Influenced By The Beatles
That Smokers Should Be Denied Access To Medicare
The Moden Technology Is A Plague Human Relationships
We All Have A Fictional Character Which We Secretly Want To Be.
Race Is An Outmoded And Increasingly Ineffective Classification System For The Human Race